A Reflection on the History of Chinese Constitutionalism of Last Century

Xiaohong Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11463-007-0003-3
2007-01-01
Frontiers of Law in China
Abstract:The academic circle often attributes frustrations of Chinese constitutionalism to the resistance of traditions. This article is of the opinion that the constitutionalism in modern China failed to be as what its framers expected precisely because of its inability to find motivation from traditions. Only when connecting itself with Chinese traditions can the “flower” of western constitutionalism get rooted in this land. “Li” (rites) is the backbone of Chinese traditions, but the rule by li, as the symbol of Chinese civilization, necessarily finds itself the focus of modern criticism on traditions. Yet, the negation and criticism that lasted for more than a century did not wipe out the imprint of history. Perhaps, in this age of unprecedented stability and easiness, we are more likely to find out the rational part implied in the rule by li as well as its particularity and lasting popularity in China. Rather than blind criticism or refusal, we should reflect, discuss, reconstruct, and rejuvenate the rule by li, and this may be an effective approach for Chinese constitutional reform.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?