Abstract:Several ASTM standards on the fracture of glued and welded joints need attention because they do not consider the Griffith energy criterion of cracking which was proposed a century ago. It is almost as if Griffith never existed because the ASTM definition of failure is the stress criterion postulated by Galileo in 1638 in which stress at failure (i.e. strength = force/area) is defined as the determinant of fracture. Irene Martinez Villegas (Villegas, Rans 2021 Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 376, 20200296. ( doi:10.1098/rsta.2020.0296 )) shows in this volume that attempts to use ASTM D5868 to standardize welded composite (carbon fibre reinforced polymer, CFRP) lap joints reveal major problems. First, the test is a low angle bend–peel test; not shear. Second, the energy required to break the joint is not emphasized so that joints may have high strength properties but also low toughness; third, the fracture force is not proportional to the lap joint area so the concept of strength independent of sample size is false; fourth, as the CFRP panels are made thicker, the strength rises at constant overlap area so the strength can be any value you want; fifth, the strength of larger joints goes down; this is the size effect noted in many bend-cracking tests, much as Galileo suggested for bent beam fracture in his famous book ‘the larger the machine, the greater its weakness'. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate that poor ASTM ‘shear strength’ standards should be replaced by a definition of welded lap joint performance based on Griffith's energy conservation argument in which fracture surface energy is the main parameter resisting failure. The foundation of this Griffith-style lap joint analysis for long cracks goes back to 1975 but has been largely ignored until now because it does not fit the Griffith equation for cracked sheets, has no ‘stress intensity factor’, and travels at constant speed, not accelerating like the standard Griffith tension crack. This study of tensile delamination shows that a long lap crack is not driven by stress near the crack but by changes in stored elastic energy in the stretched strips remote from the crack tip, while strain energy release rate is negative. It would be more appropriate to call this lap failure a tensile delamination crack. This article is part of a discussion meeting issue ‘A cracking approach to inventing new tough materials: fracture stranger than friction’.

Development of J-R Curves from Obsolete Data Using Normalization Techniques

Normalization Method for Developing J-R Curves with the LMN Function

New Data Processing Protocols to Isolate Fracture Deformations to Measure Normal and Shear Joint Stiffness

Enhancement of Constant Normal Stiffness Direct Shear Testing Protocols for Determining Geomechanical Properties of Fractures

Energizing ASTM lap joint fracture standards

Measuring J‐R curve under dynamic loading conditions using digital image correlation

Nonlinear Fracture Analysis of Delamination Crack Jumps in Laminated Composites

Cyclic R‐curve measurements for structural metallic alloys

Test-and-FE-based method for obtaining complete stress-strain curves of structural steels including fracture

Towards Fully Automatic Modelling of the Fracture Process in Quasi-Brittle and Ductile Materials: a Unified Crack Growth Criterion

Experimental research on the fatigue crack growth behaviour of Q420C

A Method of Fracture Toughness JIC Measurement Based on Digital Image Correlation and Acoustic Emission Technique

The development of creep damage constitutive equations for high Cr steel

Simplified method to identify full von Mises stress-strain curve of structural metals

Improved maximum likelihood method for P-S-N curve fitting method with small number specimens and application in T-welded joint

Quantification of the Complex Crack Geometry Effect on Fracture Resistance Using Strain-Based Finite Element Damage Analysis

Stress–strain curves of metallic materials and post‐necking strain hardening characterization: A review

Fracture parameters analysis of compact tension specimens with deflected fatigue cracks: ZK60 magnesium alloy

A new method for measuring the dynamic fracture toughness under blast loads using arc-edge rectangle with edge notches

The over-notched flexure test method for determining the fracture toughness and bridging law of laminates

An innovative way to measure fatigue crack growth without COD gauge