Factor Income Distribution: The Story behind The Statistics

Chong-En Bai,Zhenjie Qian

2010-01-01

Abstract:This paper investigates changes in aggregate labor share in China since 1978 with a particular focus on the 1995 -2007 period during which official statistics report a drop of 12.45 percentage points in labor’s share of national income. Our main findings are: (1) The reported fall in labor’s share of income (the labor share) is overstated. According to the official statistic released by the NBS (2007a), the labor share fell 5.25 percentage points from 2003 to 2004. However this dramatic decline, 42.16% of the total reported decline of the labor share from 1995 to 2007, is due to changes in the way NBS break down the income of the self-employed and stateowned and collective-owned farms; (2) For the last three decades, two main forces have been driving shifts in the labor share: (i) structural transformations between the agriculture and non-agriculture sectors (ii) shifts in the labor share within the industry sector; (3) From 1995 to 2003, these two effects are both negative and together drive down labor’s share of income by 5.48 percentage points. The structural change explains 61.31 percent of the decline and the remaining 38.69 percent of the decline is due to changes in the labor share within sectors, primarily in the industry sector; (4) Labor’s share of income in agriculture is lower than labor’s share in services. Therefore, when the service sector grows relative to the agriculture sector in the economy, the aggregate labor share of income declines; (5) Restructuring of the SOEs and expanded monopoly power are the main reasons for the decline in the labor share after 1998 in the industry sector. Relative price shifts, the factor input ratio, and biased technological progress are all insignificant forces in this decline because the substitution between factors in the industry sector is nearly unit elastic. 1. Chong-En Bai, Professor of School of Management and Economics, Tsinghua University, email: baichn@sem.tsinghua.edu.cn; 2. Zhenjie Qian, Postdoctoral Fellow of School of Management and Economics, Tsinghua University, email: qianzhj@sem.tsinghua.edu.cn.