Abstract:The problem of distributive justice has been widely discussed by Western and Chinese scholarship of Marxism. This interest results from the historical transformation of the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe at the end of the 1980s, and also from the crucial transition in China beginning in the late 1970s. By conceptualizing the basic principle of distributive justice as “reward according to effort and ability,” this paper discusses the differences between liberal thought, as exemplified by John Rawls and Robert Nozick, and the ideas of Karl Marx, from basic principles to context. It deals with the concept of “private property” or even “private ownership.” In Marx's view, the principle of distributive justice is necessarily betrayed under the condition of private ownership—the capitalist exploits workers—and the solution is the replacement of private by public ownership. Ultimately, the principle of justice is replaced by the principle of beyond justice. Nozick sees private ownership as the natural result of the principle, a condition he regards as self-ownership. Rawls shares this position with Nozick, but seeks to improve its operation with “justice as fairness,” which combines the principle of justice with the principle of beyond justice. Neither Nozick nor Rawls intuits that the principle itself would be betrayed under the condition of private ownership.

A Probe into Marx's View on Social Injustice

Enlightenment Reason and Modernity: Marx’s Critical Reconstruction

Understanding Marx's Concept of Justice

System of "-ism" and System of Justice

Justice beyond Justice——Reflection on Debate of "Marx and Justice"

Marx's Discovery,Critique and Reconstruction of the Society of Modernity

From Principle to Context: Marx versus Nozick and Rawls on Distributive Justice

Three Conceptions of Justice in Marx: to What Extent the Appropriation of Surplus Value by Capital Accords with Justice

The Social-Political Basis of Philosophy of Law——a Study on "the Approach to the Social-Political Philosophy of Law" in the Establishment of Marx's Theory of Law

Critique on Marx's Realistic State Theory and Justice of Right

Marx's Achievements in His Criticism of Proudhon——an Analysis on the Significance of The Poverty of Theory

The Practical Study of Marx's Theory of Ownership

Marx’s Concept of Fairness and the Socialist Market Economy

Marx’s Civil Society Theory

A Diachronic Study of Marx' Transcendence of Hegel's Theory of Civil Society

A Probe on Lectures of Justice and Benefit

From Theory of Justice to Theory of Morals——An Analysis based on Marxism and the Moral Point of View

A Study of Marx’s Property Rights Socialization Thought and Its Enlightenment

On Marx's Theory of Society-Subject

On Marx's Social Self-criticism

Critique on civil society:a new research horizon of Marxian theory