Abstract:We have measured the elastic properties of live cells by Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) using different tip geometries commonly used in AFM studies. Soft 4-sided pyramidal probes (spring constant = 12 and 30 mN/m, radius 20 nm), 3-sided pyramidal probes (spring constant = 100 mN/m, radius 65-75 nm), flat (circular) probes (spring constant = 63 mN/m, radius 290 nm) and spherical probes (spring constant = 43 mN/m, radius 5 μm) have been used. Cells (3T3 fibroblasts) having elastic moduli around 0.5 kPa were investigated. We found that cell measured stiffness shows a systematic dependence on tip geometry: the sharper the tip, the higher the average modulus values. We hypothesize that the blunter the tip, the larger the contact area over which the mechanical response is measured or averaged. If there are small-scale stiffer areas (like actin bundles) they will be easier to pick up by a sharp probe. This effect can be seen in the wider distribution of the histograms of the measured elastic moduli on cells. Furthermore, non-linear responses of cells may be present due to the high average pressures applied by sharp probes, which would lead to an overestimation of the Young's modulus. Pressure versus contact radius simulations for the different tip geometries for a 0.5 kPa sample suggested similar average pressure for Bio-MLCTs, PFQNM and cut tips, except spherical tips that showed much lower average pressure at the same 400 nm indentation. However, real data of the cells suggested different results. Using the same indentation depth (400 nm), PFQNM and Bio-MLCTs showed similar average pressure and it decreased for cut and spherical tips. The calculated contact area at 400 nm cell indentation, using the obtained apparent Young's modulus for each tip geometry, showed the following distribution: Bio-MLCTs < PFQNM < cut << spherical. In summary, tip geometry as well as average pressure and tip-sample contact area are important parameters to take into account when measuring mechanical properties of soft samples. The larger the tip radius, the larger the contact area that will lead to a more evenly distribution of the applied pressure.

Evaluation of Biological Cell Properties Using Dynamic Indentation Measurement

Substrate Effect on Dynamic Indentation Measurement of Biological Cell Properties

On the Determination of Elastic Moduli of Cells by AFM Based Indentation

Are elastic moduli of biological cells depth dependent or not? Another explanation using a contact mechanics model with surface tension.

Evaluating the nucleus effect on the dynamic indentation behavior of cells

Power-law Rheology Characterization of Biological Cell Properties under AFM Indentation Measurement

Surface Effects on the Spherical Indentation of Biological Film/substrate Structures

Simultaneous Measurement of Multiple Mechanical Properties of Single Cells Using AFM by Indentation and Vibration

Revealing the Nanoindentation Response of a Single Cell Using a 3D Structural Finite Element Model

Effects of surface energy and substrate on modulus determination of biological films by conical indentation

Finite Element Modelling of Nanoindentation Based Methods for Mechanical Properties of Cells

Method for quantitative measurements of the elastic modulus of biological cells in AFM indentation experiments

A novel approach for extracting viscoelastic parameters of living cells through combination of inverse finite element simulation and Atomic Force Microscopy

Influence of cantilever tip geometry and contact model on AFM elasticity measurement of cells

Spherical indentation on biological films with surface energy

Direct Characterization of Stress-Strain Relationship for Quantifying Single Cell Elasticity

Cell Visco-Elasticity Measured with Afm and Vertical Optical Trapping at Sub-Micrometer Deformations

Probing Local Cellular Mechanics by Atomic Force Microscopy with Modified Spherical Tip

Finite Element Modelling of Single Cell Based on Atomic Force Microscope Indentation Method

Evaluating Nucleus Effect On The Cell Mechanical Behavior

Cell Visco-Elasticity Measured with Afm and Optical Trapping at Sub-Micrometer Deformations