Assessing coronary angiography appropriateness——the comparison of clinic and angiograms data between Shanghai and London

WEI Meng,MA Shixin,GE Lei
2007-01-01
Journal of Clinical Cardiology
Abstract:Objective:To compare the characteristics of clinic and angiograms in patients between Shanghai and London, and assess coronary angiography appropriateness in Shanghai and London.Method:Retrospectives analysis was performed to compare the clinical characteristics of patients in Shanghai and London including age, clinical diagnosis, special tests for coronary artery disease before angiography, and angiographic results. Result:Undertaken coronary angiogram the proportion of patients aged below 50 was higher in Shanghai than in London. But patients aged above 70 were less in Shanghai (28% vs 15%, 7% vs 20% P<0.001 respectively). The proportion of chronic stable angina pectoris was lower but that of AMI were higher in Shnaghai than in London (22%:39%, P<0.01; 10% :6%, P<0.01 respectively). The proportion of patients with atypical chest pain and without symptom undertaken coronary angiogram was higher in Shanghai than in London (14%: 5%, 10%:4%,P<0.01). And the proportion of patients with miscellaneous causes was higher in Shanghai(25%:15%, P<0.01). Exercise electrocardiograms were performed less widely in Shanghai than in London (12%: 47%, P<0.01). While Holter and transthoracic echocardiograms were used much more in Shanghai than in London (63% :3%,83% :17%,P<0.01). Angiograms revealed a low proportion of two or three vessel diseases in Shanghai compared to London, (14.9%:21.3%, 11.8%:23.6% ,P<0.01), and a high proportion of normal vessels, mild and moderate vessel diseases in Shanghai(18.2%:37.0%, 9.6%:16.4%, P<0.01). The rate of positive coronary angiogram was significantly lower in Shanghai than in London if stenosis of coronary artery was more than 50% considered as positive cutpoint(44.6%:72.2%, P<0. 01).Conclusion:Compared to London, the coronary angiography appropriateness was performed not strictly in Shanghai. Medical resources were not used appropriately in Shanghai.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?