Political Conceptions and Historical Method in the Critique of Property Rights

Zhang Dun

2011-01-01

Abstract:The disputes of property rights had run through the whole history of modern political philosophy and achieved its climax in the debates between Marx and Proudhon.Marx gave a high appreciation of Proudhon's criticism of Bourgeois property rights,but also pointed out that the fundamental defect of Proudhon's viewpoint was his socialist position as a petty Bourgeois and his unhistorical comprehension on the relations of bourgeois property.According to Marx's historical understanding of property rights,we can find that the relations of Bourgeois property are not eternal but temporary,and are both historical and inevitably doomed.Obviously,Marx's historical understanding benefits from Hegelian idea.By comparing them,we notice that Marx insists on abandoning the rights of bourgeois property and advocates that all the individuals should possess the social wealth in a united way;while Hegel claims that in order to overcome the crisis of modernity,we should ignore the problems of property rights,and achieve the unity of particularity and universality through the state,though Hegel also denies the modern credo that "Private property is sacred and inviolable".