Abstract:After victory in the Anti-Japanese War, Chiang Kai-shek issued the famous radio speech “Letter to Soldiers and Civilians of the Whole Nation as well as the Peoples of the World after the Victory of the Anti-Japanese War.” The main idea of this speech was long interpreted as “returning virtue for malice” (or “good for evil”), a basic principle of the Kuomintang's policy towards Japan. Many scholars who have considered the returning virtue for malice policy in the postwar period include the following major issues: first, China repatriated Japanese prisoners of war and the Japanese diaspora with mercy; second, China allowed the Tenno, or imperial, system to be preserved in Japan; third, China did not participate in the occupation of Japan; and fourth, China gave up the right to ask for war reparations from Japan. This article examines the above four issues to reevaluate the returning virtue for malice policy. The first issue seems to reflect the Chinese national character of being lenient with others. However, it was in fact due to Chiang's anti-Communist strategy and the declared policy of the United States of eradicating Japan's influence in China. With regard to the second issue, Chiang's attitude was merely to let the Japanese people make their own choice, while the fate of the Japanese Tenno system was entirely determined by the US occupation authority, on which Chiang had little influence. The third issue was mainly the outcome of Chiang's focus on domestic political struggle in the postwar era in China. As for war reparations, China actually made efforts to obtain them in the beginning, but had to give up its right eventually. The decision-making process in the Kuomintang government was restrained by American policy and subordinated to Japanese pressure. Thus, it is not persuasive to summarize the basic principle of Kuomintang postwar policy towards Japan as returning virtue for malice.

Decisions and Actions on the Withdrawal of Americans and Troops in China during the Initial Period of the Anti-Japanese War

Zhang Zhidong's Negotiations with Japan during the 1900 War

Paradise or Hell Hole?: U.S. Marines in Post–World War II China

The Xi'an Incident and Japan's Policies toward China

The Qingdao Pattern and U.S.-Chinese Crisis Management: the KMT, the CCP, and the U.S. Marines in Qingdao During the Chinese Civil War (1945–1949)

The Nationalist Government's Responses to the Changing European Situation: Chinese Diplomacy around the Outbreak of World War Ⅱ

A Study of American Policy of Travel Restrictions towards China during the Cold War:Explorations Centering on the Johnson Administration

Embracing mainstream international society: Chiang Kai-shek’s diplomatic strategy against Japan

A Study on the Japanese Army's Strategic Timing Selection in Light of the Occurrence of Nanking Massacre

Loss of Confidence:Using Chiang Kai-shek’s Diary to Look at Sino-American Relations in the Later Period of the Resistance War against Japan

The Chinese Rediscovery of the Special Relationship: the Jinan Incident As a Turning Point in Sino-American Relations

JinanTragedy and Chiang Kai-shek's Strategic Decisions of Northern Expedition Through Roundabout Route

Re-examination of the Peking Government’s Participation in World War Ⅰ

Republican Government’s Overseas Remittance Control and Its Impact during the Anti-Japanese War Period

On the Change of Chinese Intellectuals; Diplomatic Stand to Japan around Anti-Japanese War: With a Focus on China Institute of Pacific Relations

The Beginning of the Sino-Japanese War and International Politics in East Asia in the 1930s: Focusing on the Protracted Course of the War

An Initial Exploration of the National Resuscitation Day around the Anti-Japanese War

The re-examination of Chiang Kai-shek's returning virtue for malice policy towards Japan after the victory of the Anti-Japanese War

A Study of the Japanese Anti-China Propaganda on the Manchurian Problem Around September 18 Incident——With Concentration on Japan Institute of Pacific Relations

A Tentative Approach to Japan's Investment in China during the Anti-Japanese War

On the Influence of the United States on the May 4th Movement