Comparative Advantage and Institutional Arrangement

Hou Jingchuan,Huang Zuhui,Qian Wenrong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-6162.2006.04.004

2006-01-01

Abstract:Based on three assumptions of "Comparative Advantage", "Limited (Value) Rationality", and "Dualistic Structure of Institution (rule + organization)", citing the famous instance of "England & Portugal" given by David Ricardo, this paper performs a systematic exploration on the effect of comparative advantage conditions on institutional arrangement. It is found that the comparative advantage conditions of the two sides play a crucial role on their institutional choice, both on their choice for rule arrangement and on their choice for organization arrangement. In respect of rule arrangement, the fit rules ensuring the specialization of the two sides will not exist until the comparative advantage between them become large enough to bring both of them acceptable division gain, and will lose the necessity of existence when it enlarges to exceed the "Natural Division Point". As for organization arrangement, the absolute disadvantage side is more efficient than the absolute advantage one as the organizer supplying the rules, given that the absolute cost of rule supply is constant.