When Informal Institution Encounters Formal Rule: Evidence from the Government Procurement in China

Shenghua Lu,Hui Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4068757
2022-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:The relationship between informal institutions and formal rules has attracted scholarly attention in many decades. Taking the allocation of Chinese government procurements as an example, this paper documents the importance of informal institution in acquiring procurements and how this effect is moderated by formal rules. A tale of two companies is first introduced to elaborate how companies compete for government procurements by taking advantage of informal institutions while balancing formal rules. Then focusing on a certain type of informal institutions, namely the political connections, we establish an original dataset by combining the transaction records of government procurement with the executives’ information of listed firms. Quantitative evidence shows that firms establishing political connections by recruiting former government officials win more public procurements in the connected jurisdictions. In addition, special methods except for public invitation are more likely to be tailored for the connected firms. With the development of formal rules, the effects of informal connections are weakened, while not disappeared. This paper provides micro evidence about the interplay of informal institutions and formal rules, in which process also advances the understanding of the allocation of government procurement in a transitional economy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?