Justice, Loyalty and Solidarity: On the Social Criticism Theories of Rorty and Walzer

Zhang Guoqing,Diao Xiaohang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14167/j.zjss.2013.04.011
2013-01-01
Abstract:Richard Rorty put forward the term of "justice as larger loyalty", which was a pragmatic interpretation for John Rawls's Kantian justice theory. Loyalty is an internally conflicted concept, it has three components, that is the recognition of the "context" in a particular relationship, the affirmation of that relationship by a loyal agent and a set of values or local principles. When the third component is prominent, loyalty is more reflective and distanced, when the second component is prominent, loyalty slips into unreflective commitment. Rorty and Micheal Walzer both emphasized the contexts of social criticism as well as the relation between loyalty and social criticism, and recognized loyalty as an appropriate quality of social critics. Rorty paid more attention to the historical and cultural dimensions of social criticism, and showed sympathy for the common fate of mankind, while Walzer paid more attention to the political attention of social criticism, and showed his concern over social reality.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?