Abstract:The importance of the interaction between groundwater and surface water is increasingly being recognized for both understanding and managing water systems. Many efforts have been made to characterize and quantify groundwater–surface water exchange. In particular, temperature–based methods have quickly established themselves given their monetary and practical advantages. In the last 15 years, several methods for interpreting passive temperature time series measured in the streambed have been developed. Still, the benchmarking of these methods has only been carried out in specific and distinct hydrological conditions. This article aims to fill this research gap by benchmarking the performance of six commonly used methods for deriving seepage fluxes using a two-year-long temperature time series covering various meteorological and thermal conditions. This work compares three analytical methods that calculate seepage flux using the amplitude and/or phase of the temperature signals, and three numerical methods that use different schemes to inversely solve the one–dimensional heat transport equation in the streambed. The temperature measurements were made in the context of an international dispute between Chile and Bolivia over the status and use of the waters of the Silala River, Northern Chile. Flux estimations are tested against Darcy's flux derived from measured hydraulic gradient and hydraulic conductivity. Flux estimations from the benchmarked methods ranged from −0.5 to 3.5 m/d (with positive fluxes directed downwards), whereas fluxes estimated using Darcy's law ranged from 0.5 to 6 m/d. Results show that the amplitude method is the best–performing method. This method is best suited for estimating the direction of the fluxes, while the method using both the thermal amplitude and phase is best suited for monthly flux trends, and the combination of a Local Polynomial (LP) method and a Maximum Likelihood Estimator (MLE) method (LPMLEn) is appropriate for estimating flux in transient conditions. The use of heat as a tracer proved to be an effective tool for monitoring groundwater–surface water exchange in a river reach for two years, and yielded exchange flux estimates with lower point-scale variability than Darcy's law.

Flux-Variance Method for Latent Heat and Carbon Dioxide Fluxes in Unstable Conditions

Estimation of Turbulent Fluxes Using the Flux-Variance Method over an Alpine Meadow Surface in the Eastern Tibetan Plateau

A variational method for estimating surface fluxes with mass conservation constraint

Water Flux Characterization Through Hydraulic Head and Temperature Data Assimilation: Numerical Modeling and Sandbox Experiments

Discrepancy and Applicability of Various Similarity Functions in Flux Calculations under Stable Conditions

Using the Sensible Heat Flux Eddy Covariance-Based Exchange Coefficient to Calculate Latent Heat Flux from Moisture Mean Gradients Over Snow

Representing the Heat-to-Moisture Transport Efficiency in Stable Conditions: an Extension of Two Different Approaches

Turbulent Variance Characteristics of Temperature and Humidity over a Non-Uniform Land Surface for an Agricultural Ecosystem in China

Improving Computation of Sensible Heat Flux over a Water Surface Using the Variational Method

Application of the Hilbert–Huang Transform to the Estimation of Air-Sea Turbulent Fluxes

Effects of Surface Source/sink Distributions on the Flux–gradient Similarity in the Unstable Surface Layer

An Alternative Approach for CO2 Flux Correction Caused by Heat and Water Vapour Transfer

Ground heat flux determination based on near-surface soil hydro-thermodynamics

Numerical Investigation of Observational Flux Partitioning Methods for Water Vapor and Carbon Dioxide

Physical Mechanism of Vertical Gradient of Pressure Flux and Its Impact on Turbulent Flux Estimation

Comparison Of Latent Heat Flux Estimates Over Australia

A Study on Estimating the Contributions of Storage and Advection Term for Evaluating Surface Flux

Groundwater–surface water exchange from temperature time series: A comparative study of heat tracer methods

A Temperature Prediction-Correction Method for Estimating Surface Soil Heat Flux from Soil Temperature and Moisture Data

Computing Surface Concentration Fluxes of Trace Gases from A Variational Method Using Measured Variance and Single-Level Concentration Data

Tracing the soil water flux in variably saturated zones using temperature data