Clinical significance of mechanical ventilation in the treatment of cerebral vascular disease with respiratory failure:a case-control study

Ji-hong ZHU,Xiao-yan XUE

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-6966.2008.01.007

2008-01-01

Abstract:Objective To investigate the value of mechanical ventilation in treatment of cerebral vascular disease(CVD) with respiratory failure.Methods 110 CVD patients with respiratory failure,aged 36～99,consecutively admitted in the ICU during 8 years underwent mechanical ventilation,and 78 of them aged≥65(with an average age of 74.6±6.4) were used as ventilation group.118 CVD patients with respiratory failure treated in the same ICU and in the same period,aged 76.6±7.3(65～94) ,who had the indication of ventilation but refused it were used as control group.Relevant data,including the demographical data,medical expenses,payment means,family economic condition,underlying diseases,vital signs,blood gas analysis results,APACHEⅡ score,hospitalization time,ventilation time,and outcome,etc.,were analyzed.Results ① There is no significant differences in age,gender,and APACHEⅡ score of between the two groups(all P >0.05) .② There were no significant differences in hospitalization days and mortality between the two groups(both P >0.05) .The APACHEⅡ scores of the patients in both groups were 20～42,and the 46 cases with the scores>30 all failed to survive.③The average medical expense of the ventilation group was(38 659±39 809) yuan,much more greater than that of the control group [(19 863±28 458) yuan].④ The proportion of those enjoying medical services at state expense of the ventilation group was 96.2%(75/78) ,significantly higher than that of the control group(79%,93/118,P <0.05) .Conclusion The outcome of the CVD patients treated by ventilation is poor.The patients aged ≥65 cannot get benefit from ventilation,and the cost of ventilation is much more enormous.