Abstract:Individuals with bounded rationality may make incorrect decisions regarding innovation projects. Organizational decision mechanisms aim to minimize the impact of individual fallibility and integrate collective wisdom. In recent years, consensus mechanism has posed a challenge to the traditional hierarchy, but its superiority in different decision scenarios is still unknown. We created decision scenarios based on positions (middle manager or grassroots employee) of the proposer of the innovation project, market volatility, and decision timeliness. Simulation results using Agent Based Modeling indicate the following: If the proposer is a middle manager and decision timeliness is unimportant, consensus in low-density networks is preferred; otherwise, hierarchy is preferred. If the proposer is a grassroots employee, the best-performing mechanism, in order, is consensus in low-density networks, consensus in high-density networks, and hierarchy as the discount interest rate increases. Market volatility drives the advance of the two critical points of the discount interest rate. Furthermore, we propose a hybrid organizational decision mechanism that can balance authority and consensus. It combines the high decision accuracy of consensus with the high decision efficiency of hierarchy, addressing the long decision time in consensus and the information asymmetry and information loss in hierarchy. Simulation results show that the proposed hybrid decision mechanism is only slightly inferior to consensus mechanism when market volatility is very low or decision timeliness is unimportant.

The mechanism to cope with the uncertainty in project management

Moderating Effects of Uncertainty on the Relationship between Risk Management and Information Systems Project Performance

Project Uncertainty, Management Practice and Project Performance: an Empirical Analysis on Customized Information Systems Development Projects

On Uncertainty, Ambiguity, and Complexity in Project Management

The management of innovation projects based on uncertainty and complexity

Choosing suitable project control modes to improve the knowledge integration under different uncertainties

Overview and Prospects of Uncertain Intelligent Design for Complex Products

The mechanism of technological innovation in the environment of knowledge agglomeration and uncertainty

Comparison and Design of Organizational Decision Mechanisms

The Project Management at the Visual Angle of Harmonious Management Theory

A Guide To Deal With Uncertainties In Software Project Management

Uncertainty Processing and Risk Monitoring in Construction Projects Using Hierarchical Probabilistic Relational Models

Two Empirical Uncertain Models for Project Scheduling Problem

An Uncertainty Analysis Approach to Multidisciplinary Design Optimization.

Uncertainty, opportunistic behavior, and governance in construction projects: The efficacy of contracts

Propagation and Management of Uncertainties in Simulation-Based Collaborative Systems Design

Control Risk for Multimode Resource-Constrained Project Scheduling Problems under Hybrid Uncertainty

Uncertainty Theory-Based Structural Reliability Analysis and Design Optimization under Epistemic Uncertainty

A Review of Uncertainty Management Theory: Conception, Introduction and Future Directions

Methodology for Managing the Effect of Uncertainty in Simulation-Based Design

A Reliability Based Multidisciplinary Design Optimization Method with Multi-Source Uncertainties