Abstract:Background: Self-regulated learning refers to the monitoring and controlling of one's own cognitive performance before, during, and after a learning episode. Previous literature suggested that self-regulated learning had a significant relationship with academic achievement, but not all self-regulated learning strategies exerted the same influences. Using an invalid strategy may waste the limited psychological resources, which will cause the ego depletion effect. The present meta-analysis study intended to search for the best self-regulated learning strategies and inefficient strategies for Chinese students in elementary and secondary school, and analyzed the critical phases of self-regulated learning according to Zimmerman's theory. The moderating effects of gender, grade, and publication year were also analyzed. Methods: Empirical studies which conducted in real teaching situations of elementary and secondary education were systematically searched using Chinese academic databases. Studies focused on undergraduate students, students of special education, or online learning environments were excluded. Fifty-five cross-sectional studies and four intervention studies (which generated 264 independent samples) were included with a total sample size of 23,497 participants. Random effects model was chosen in the current meta-analysis, and publication bias was also examined. Results: The results indicated that the overall effect size of self-regulated learning on academic achievement was small for primary and secondary school students in China. The effect sizes of self-efficacy, task strategies, and self-evaluation were relatively higher than other strategies. Self-regulated learning strategies have the largest effect size on science disciplines (including mathematics and physics). Performance phase and self-reflection phase are key phases of self-regulated learning. From 1998 to 2016, the effect size between self-regulated learning and academic achievement was gradually decreasing. Conclusions: The main findings of the current study showed that self-efficacy, task strategies, and self-evaluation were key self-regulated learning strategies for Chinese students. Performance phase and self-reflection phase played significant roles in the process of self-regulated learning. Future studies need to include more intervention studies with rigorous treatment fidelity control and provide more empirical evidence from online learning, so as to compare the different effects of self-regulated learning between traditional education and online education.

Process and Influence Factors of Learning Strategy Selection

Experience-driven discovery of planning strategies

Individuals with anxiety and depression use atypical decision strategies in an uncertain world

Strategy Selection under Metacognitive Monitoring and the Practical Implications for Self -Regulated Learning of College English

Knowing the learning strategy is not enough to use it: Example in reading strategies for Japanese undergraduates

Reviewer #2 (public Review): Individuals with Anxiety and Depression Use Atypical Decision Strategies in an Uncertain World

What are the mechanisms underlying metacognitive learning?

The Strategy Selection in Mental Arithmetic

How undergraduate students learn: uncovering interrelationships between factors that support self-regulated learning and strategy use

The Effect of Decision Strategy on Self-Control Choice

The Interplay of Cognitive Load, Learners' Resources and Self-regulation

What Are the Effects of Self-Regulation Phases and Strategies for Chinese Students? A Meta-Analysis of Two Decades Research of the Association Between Self-Regulation and Academic Performance

Learning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision-Making

Learning to Choose: Behavioral Dynamics Underlying the Initial Acquisition of Decision Making

An Investigation of the Learning Strategy of High School Students

Meta-Learning Strategies through Value Maximization in Neural Networks

Self-Regulated Learning: The Interactive Influence of Metacognitive Awareness and Goal-Setting

Learning in Games: Neural Computations Underlying Strategic Learning

How do Information Source Selection Strategies Influence Users' Learning Outcomes'.

Strategic Decision Making under Uncertainty: the Role of Analogical Reasoning