Abstract:As indicator weights obtaining is often difficult in all types of evaluation, this paper describes an approach to improve the indicator weights of scientific and technological competitiveness evaluation of Chinese universities. As a public institution funded by Chinese government, the research center for Chinese science evaluation of Wuhan University has completed five annual evaluations for the scientific and technological competitiveness of Chinese universities since 2005, whose abundant and reliable data motivated us to try to improve the weights obtained by the AHP (analytical hierarchy process). Based on these data, we calculated the objective weights of the indicator using the representative mathematical methods of the least square and the variation coefficient. As the weights of AHP can be influenced by the knowledge, experience and preference of experts and the calculated objective weights neglect the subjective judgement information, we integrated the subjective and objective weights by respectively using the additive and multiplicative model to reflect both the subjective considerations of experts and the objective information, and obtained three kinds of integrative weights. Finally, we selected the integrative weights of multiplicative model as the best weights by comparing and analyzing the evaluation results in 2005 and 2009 of each kind of weights. The results show that the evaluation effect of the weights of multiplicative model is indeed the best for all types of Chinese universities among these kinds of weights, and the experts and university principals enquired also basically reached a consensus on the university rankings of the integrative weights of multiplicative model.

Positive Analysis and Construction of Evaluation Index of the Scientific and Technological Innovation Platform of Colleges and Universities

Construction of Evaluation Index System of High-Tech Industries in Hebei Province

Establishment and Application of Scientific Research Innovation Capability Evaluation Index System for Postgraduates of Science and Engineering in Colleges and Universities

Study and exploration on assessment mechanism of undergraduate innovation program

Financial Performance Evaluation System of colleges in Shaanxi Province

A Study on the Evaluation Index System of Innovation and Entrepreneurship Education for Undergraduate Students Majoring in Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences

ON THE EVALUATION MODEL OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH ACHIEVEMENTS AND THEIR GAUGING SYSTEM IN COLLEGES/DEPARTMENTS OF UNIVERSITIES

Analysis of the Innovation and Result of Chinese Universities and Subjects Evaluation in 2012

A Study on Index System of Evaluation for Innovative Performance in High-tech Sections

The Fuzzy and Comprehensive Assessment of the Effects of Application of Instruments and Facilities in Colleges and Universities

Evaluation on S&T Innovative Capacity of Chinese Universities Based on Principal Component Analysis

Evaluation scheme design of college information construction based on a combined algorithm

Study on evaluation index system of China private college ranking

The Analysis of Innovation of Chinese Scientic&Technologic Listed Companies

Researching on the Performance Evaluation Index System of Industry-University-Research Institute Collaboration

Research and exploration on constructing benefit evaluation index system of laboratories in colleges and universities

The Evaluation Of The Universities' Science And Technology Comprehensive Strength Based On Management Efficiency

Research on the Quality of Sci-tech Novelty Retrieval Institution in University Library

Design on the Training Evaluation System of Scientific Research Institute Based on the Chinese Academy of Sciences: An Empirical Study

Analysis of results and innovation of the idea and method of Chinese university evaluation in 2012

An approach to improve the indicator weights of scientific and technological competitiveness evaluation of Chinese universities