The Choice Logic of Differentiated Policy Tools for Central Government Promotion of Policy Pilots:A Qualitative Comparative Analysis of 20 Cases Chinese Full Text
李强彬,支广东,李延伟
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-2486.2023.01.010
2023-01-01
Abstract:The policy pilot has been widely regarded as one of the governance models with Chinese characteristics which helps explain the Chinese miracle. However,the existing studies analyze the government’s pilot operation process from the perspectives of the occurrence mechanism,promotion logic,or knowledge production in the policy pilot; they pay scant attention to the central government’s choice of differentiated policy tools to promote policy pilots. From the two dimensions of central intervention and local autonomy,this paper examines four types of policy tools the central government uses to promote policy pilots: directive,incentive,inducement,and autonomy. Furthermore,this paper constructs the policy attribute-policy environment analysis framework for policy tool selection,and then uses qualitative comparative analysis to analyze 20 pilot cases initiated by the central government.This analysis reveals the generative mechanisms of differentiated policy tool selection. This study found that the type of policy tools chosen by the central government is influenced by the clarity of the pilot content,the urgency of the issue,the difficulty of implementation,and the interaction between policy support and authority pressure,which forms three different logics: internal and external composite drive,external authority drive,and external policy drive. Among them,the clarity of content is the precondition for the choice of policy tools,the urgency of issues regulates the degree of central intervention,and the pressure of authority highlights the central government’s overall control over policy tools. This paper enriches our understanding of China’s policy pilot mechanisms and differential promotion modes. The study’s findings have implications for the scientific design of policy pilots,including securing the achievement of policy pilot objectives and matching policy tools according to each pilot’s target groups,policy attributes,and policy environment characteristics.