Systematic Review of Brachytherapy Compared with Stent Placement in Treatment of Dysphagia from Cancer of Esophageal and Gastro-Esophageal Junction

罗宏涛,王小虎,田金徽,杨克虎,拜争刚,姜雷
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-5269.2008.17.010
2008-01-01
Abstract:OBJECTIVE:To evaluate the efficacy of brachytherapy compared with stent placement in the treatment of dysphagia from cancer of esophageal and gastro-esophageal junction.METHODS:CBMdisc,VIP,CNKI,Cochrane Library,PubMed,Embeas etc.were searched by a computer and eight major Chinese journals of oncology were searched by manual.The randomized controlled trials compared brachytherapy with stent placement in the treatment of dysphagia from cancer of esophageal and gastro-esophageal junction were included.The trial methodological quality and extracted data were assossed by 2 reviewers independently,and the statistical software,RevMan 4.2.10,was used.RESULTS:Four English articls were included(269 patients),and the methodological qualities of all the trials were Grade C,and the baselines of dysphagia scores before the treatment were similar.The results of Meta analysis showed that the complications had a statistical defferrence between the brachytherapy group and stent placement group(RR 0.50,95%CI 0.32,0.79);while there was no statistical difference at dysphagia recurrent(RR 1.03,95%CI 0.63,1.67),mortality of short time(one month RR 1.09,95%CI 0.62,1.93;three months RR 0.90,95%CI 0.64,1.27;six months RR 1.20,95% CI 0.95,1.52)in the two groups.The patients in the brachytherapy group had overall better quality of life than those in the stent placement group.CONCLUSIONS:Brachytherapy has the same efficacy in relieving dysphagia from cancer of esophageal and gastro-oesophageal junction as the stent placement,and has the low incidence of complications and long-term better quality of life.However,it should be cautious of interpreting this conclusion due to a few trials and the general low methodological quality.So,more rationally designed and strictly executed RCTs with large samples will be necessary.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?