Abstract:The piecewise growth mixture model (PGMM) has been a very popular analytical approach in recent studies of longitudinal data. PGMM builds on the piecewise growth model (PGM) and the growth mixture model (GMM). It is used to locate the turning point of growth trajectory as well as to identify the latent class of the population. It is particularly useful in detecting the non-continuous growing trend in a heterogeneous population. A simplified version of the model, the latent class growth analysis (LCGA), has also been often used with a restriction on the variance of PGMM. Understandably, factors affecting PGM and GMM will affect the estimates and performance of PGMM. These factors may include the change of the slope, the distance of latent classes, and the sample size. PGMM being developed from the two growth-related models (PGM, GMM) also attempts to analyze the growth pattern in latent growth trajectory as a special and newly emerged issue. Even for models with the same distance, their different slopes can be combined to form different patterns. This issue has not been fully explored in previous literature. Yet in empirical studies, factors such as the distance of the latent classes, the growth pattern, the existing criteria of model fit indices, and the precision of parameter estimates are well worth examining issues. In the present simulation study, a two-class-two-period model was adopted. The three simulation conditions being considered were:the sample size, the distance of latent class, and the pattern of the growth trajectory. The sample size was set to be 100, 200 and 500. The distance of the latent classes was defined as the squared Mahalanobis distance (SMD), with 1.5, 3 and 5 being used to represent the small, medium and large distance of latent classes respectively. Four different types of growth pattern were selected to represent one parallel and three non-parallel patterns. Finally, the LCGA was selected as the reference model to see whether PGMM could be further simplified or not. The results showed that: (1) the distance between the latent classes (SMD) was a crucial factor that influenced the model selection and parameter estimation. Large distance would lead to consistent BIC and entropy when the right models were selected; while small distance (SMD = 1.5) would not. (2) When mixture modeling was taken into consideration, it was suggested that a sample size of at least 200 should be used. BIC index should be the preferred choice to be used for model selection; the entropy, ARI and other indices were also recommended to further reference. (3) The pattern of the growth trajectory would affect model selection; specifically, non-parallel patterns of the trajectory would help model selection (higher entropy and higher total hit ratio) for medium distance (SMD=3) and medium sample size (N=200) conditions. However, as compared to LCGA, the pattern of the growth trajectory had little influence on PGMM. (4) Parameter estimation was affected by the sample size and distance of latent classes. Parameter estimates would become more precise as the sample size and the distance increased. (5) ARI was a reasonably good index belonging to the recovery indices family. ARI was highly correlated with the total hit ratio and thus would lead to recommendations of models closer to the true model.

Methods Comparison of Piecewise Growth Modeling

The Effects of Individually Varying Times of Observations on Growth Parameter Estimations in Piecewise Growth Model

A Two-Step Estimation Method for Grouped Data with Connections to the Extended Growth Curve Model and Partial Least Squares Regression.

Factors of Piecewise Growth Mixture Model:Distance and Pattern

Piecewise Growth Mixture Models and Its Current Researches

Bayesian Methods and Model Selection for Latent Growth Curve Models with Missing Data

Selecting a linear mixed model for longitudinal data: Repeated measures analysis of variance, covariance pattern model, and growth curve approaches.

Bayesian Approach to Non-ignorable Missingness in Latent Growth Models

Interaction Effects in Latent Growth Models: Evaluation of Alternative Estimation Approaches

Growth Curve Modeling to Studying Change: A Comparison of Approaches Using Longitudinal Dyadic Data with Distinguishable Dyads

Model Selection Criteria for Latent Growth Models Using Bayesian Methods

Investigating Approaches to Estimating Covariate Effects in Growth Mixture Modeling: A Simulation Study

Understanding Variation in Longitudinal Data Using Latent Growth Mixture Modeling

Bayesian Analysis Of Longitudinal Data Using Growth Curve Models

Fitting Structural Equation Model Trees and Latent Growth Curve Mixture Models in Longitudinal Designs: The Influence of Model Misspecification

Mixed Effects Multivariate Adaptive Splines Model for the Analysis of Longitudinal and Growth Curve Data

Comparing predictive abilities of longitudinal child growth models

Comparison of the Parameter Estimators in Hierarchical Generalized Linear Models

Evaluation of A Bayesian Approach to Estimating Nonlinear Mixed-Effects Mixture Models

Two-step growth mixture model to examine heterogeneity in nonlinear trajectories

The Effect of Model Misspecification on Growth Mixture Model Class Enumeration