An Inquiry into the “Cannot” in One’s Innate Knowledge——A Reflection and Investigation on Confucian Retional of Morality

Ding Wei-xiang

2005-01-01

Abstract:Innate knowledge refers to internal fossilization and intellectual expression of one’s moral rational. The “can” of innate knowledge indicates the moral concern and control over the realistic world whereas the “cannot” of it expresses the isolation and transcendence of the reality. Mencius, Zhang Zai and Wang Yangming all exploited the issue of the “can” of innate knowledge, but Xu Ai, a pupil of Wang Yangming, started the tradition of exploring that of the “cannot” of it. From a historical perspective, the boundaries between “can” and “cannot” of innate knowledge showed the indication of steadily varying. The issue of the “cannot” was the common academic concern in the Pre-Qin days but the “can” rose as the main concern in the Song and the Ming Dynasty. Zhang Zai showed interest in the “can” while Wang Yangming in the “cannot”. The situation remained until Xiong Shili who concentrated his study on the “can”. Varying as the academic focus has been on the issue, the frontiers of the “can” of innate knowledge have always been extending with deepening of the subject’s experience and acceptation, and with the “cannot” as the prerequisite and realistic basis of the “can”.