Abstract:Heritability enrichment analysis is an important means of exploring the genetic architecture of complex traits in human genetics. Heritability enrichment is typically defined as the proportion of an SNP subset explained heritability, divided by the proportion of SNPs. Heritability enrichment enables better study of underlying complex traits, such as functional variant/gene subsets, biological networks and metabolic pathways detected through integrating explosively increased omics data. This would be beneficial for genomic prediction of disease risk in humans and genetic values estimation of important economical traits in livestock and plant species. However, in livestock, factors affecting the heritability enrichment estimation of complex traits have not been examined. Previous studies on humans reported that the frequencies, effect sizes, and levels of linkage disequilibrium (LD) of underlying causal variants (CVs) would affect the heritability enrichment estimation. Therefore, the distribution of heritability across the genome should be fully considered to obtain the unbiased estimation of heritability enrichment. To explore the performance of different heritability enrichment models in livestock populations, we used the VanRaden, GCTA and α models, assuming different α values, and the LDAK model, considering LD weight. We simulated three types of phenotypes, with CVs from various minor allele frequency (MAF) ranges: genome-wide (0.005 ≤ MAF ≤ 0.5), common (0.05 ≤ MAF ≤ 0.5), and uncommon (0.01 ≤ MAF < 0.05). The performances of the models with two different subsets (one of which contained known CVs and the other consisting of randomly selected markers) were compared to verify the accuracy of heritability enrichment estimation of functional variant sets. Our results showed that models with known CV subsets provided more robust enrichment estimation. Models with different α values tended to provide stable and accurate estimates for common and genome-wide CVs (relative deviation 0.5–2.2%), while tending to underestimate the enrichment of uncommon CVs. As the α value increased, enrichments from 15.73% higher than true value (i.e., 3.00) to 48.93% lower than true value for uncommon CVs were observed. In addition, the long-range LD windows (e.g., 5000 kb) led to large bias of the enrichment estimations for both common and uncommon CVs. Overall, heritability enrichment estimations were sensitive for the α value assumption and LD weight consideration of different models. Accuracy would be greatly improved by using a suitable model. This study would be helpful in understanding the genetic architecture of complex traits and provides a reference for genetic analysis in the livestock population.

Estimation of heritability for threshold traits in livestock using GLMM method

Methodology of Genetic Analysis for Discrete Traits of Livestock

Comparison of the Efficiency of BLUP and GBLUP in Genomic Prediction of Immune Traits in Chickens.

Methodology of Predicting Additive Polygene Effect for Hereditary Resistance Using Generalized Linear Method

Methodology of Mapping Quantitative Trait Loci for Ordinal Traits of Disease Resistance in Livestock.

Estimation of Genetic Parameters for Body Weight in Chinese Simmental Cattle Using Random Regression Model

Mixed Linear Model Approaches for Analyzing Genetic Models of Complex Quantitative Traits

Factors Affecting the Accuracy of Genomic Selection for Agricultural Economic Traits in Maize, Cattle, and Pig Populations

Transforming estimated breeding values from observed to probability scale: how to make categorical data analyses more efficient

Model Comparison of Heritability Enrichment Analysis in Livestock Population

Bayesian Methods for Estimating Gebvs of Threshold Traits

Semiparametric Regression Based Method for Association Analysis of Multi-Region Haplotype and Longitudinal Trait

Integration of Ssgwas and ROH Analyses for Uncovering Genetic Variants Associated with Reproduction Traits in Large White Pigs.

Estimation of Genetic Parameters for Early Growth Traits in Luzhong Mutton Sheep

Hierarchical Generalized Linear Mixed Model for Genome-wide Association Analysis

Marker-based estimation of heritability in immortal populations

Accuracy of Marker Assisted Genetic Evaluation under the Major Gene-Polygene Mixed Inheritance Models

Comparative Study of Estimation Methods for Genomic Breeding Values

Using Different Single-Step Strategies to Improve the Efficiency of Genomic Prediction on Body Measurement Traits in Pig

Factors Affecting GEBV Accuracy with Single-Step Bayesian Models

Best Linear Unbiased Prediction of Genomic Breeding Values Using a Trait-Specific Marker-Derived Relationship Matrix