NAMDANG’S THEORY ON THE NATURES OF HUMANS AND NON-HUMAN LIVING BEINGS AND HIS DEVELOPMENT OF ZHU XI’S THEORIES
형려국,Lin Xi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.18399/acta.2016.19.2.009
2016-01-01
Acta Koreana
Abstract:This article examines a thesis by Namdang, a Confucian scholar in Choson Korea, on the natures of humans and non-human living beings, using Zhu Xi's li (.) - qi (.) theory. Regarding the sameness or difference between li and qi, Zhu Xi formulated different opinions in his early and later life and was also at times inconsistent in his works of a certain period. To a certain extent, Zhu Xi's thoughts lacked coherence, which led to subsequent debates. In seeking to develop Zhu Xi's li-qi theory, Namdang put forward his original thesis of Trichotomous Nature, which significantly enriched Zhu Xi's ideas. The "nature transcending the appearance of things" (K. ch'ohyonggi .) refers to a pure xing (K. song.; nature), concerned with only li without considering the influence of qi from the perspective of a unitary source (K. irwon ; one source). At this stage, everything shares the same li and xing. The "nature originated from temperament" (K. in'gijil ) demonstrates the shared nature for the same species as well as the difference in nature across species, thus being an endowment-dependent li. At this stage, for the same species, they share the same li, qi, and xing, while for varying species, there is a difference in li, qi, and xing. The "nature mixed with temperament" (K. chapkijil ) considers the xing of pure qizhi (K. kijil ; physical temperament) in which all creatures differ. It is thus a concept that demonstrates the particularity in all things, with varying differences in li, qi, and xing.