Reciprocity and the Formation of International Law Rules

Jiang Shi-bo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-6274.2010.01.006

2010-01-01

Abstract:Reciprocity plays an important role in the formation of international law, as well assecurity of binding force of international law. Many scholars have been dealt with these. However, the past study mainly lied in the level of experience described, did not enter the scientific level. In recent years, the game theory has been introduced into the research of international law which opened a new window to reveal the substance of the rules of international law. Especially, in this respect, Parisi observed the formation of rules from the perspective of game theory and its insightful connotation to international law. Based on his five types of game pattern about social existence, he classified reciprocity as structural reciprocity, induced reciprocity and stochastic reciprocity. These patterns of reciprocity in the absence of central authority in international relations, may lead to various forms of cooperation, thereby, to the formation of different rules of international law. It can be said that reciprocity constitutes a meta-rule of international relations. However, reciprocity can not explain all of the formation of international rules. Altruism arising from strong reciprocity will be difficult to be explained in the framework of reciprocity,which explains such values and institutions as international human rights and international common interests disadvantage to certain countries.