Abstract:Technological mediation theorists (such as Don Ihde and Verbeek) believe that human beings’ moral actions can be transformed through technological artefacts to constitute a “good life”. This paper, however, critically analyses two understandings of technological mediation, (1) technological mediation is something between humans and the world (prominent in Don Ihde), and (2) technological mediation is a direct constitutive effect (prominent in Verbeek), which will inevitably lead to the problem of “moral suspension” that I define. In the first understanding (following Zygmunt Bauman), the causal relations between moral actions and actual consequences are distanced from each other because of the “interval” effects of technological artefacts. In the second understanding (following Jean Baudrillard), designers are just “simulating” moralities in specific use and design contexts. Thus, moral realities are ultimately replaced by moral “simulacra”. Then, I argue that to overcome the problem of “moral suspension,” rather than distancing actions from their consequences or simulating moralities in specific scenarios, two possible approaches may be needed, the Way of Zhuangzi who declined to use any adroit technology to improve efficiency, thereby clarifying the relationship between moral actions and consequences; and the attitude of Bauman, who motivated our moral consciences and moral sensitivities, thereby reflecting the side effects of technological mediations and systems. In the end, I conclude that both of these two approaches are too difficult to universally apply, and the most viable approach is to use what Confucius called “the Doctrine of the Mean,” i.e., seeking a balance between the two approaches. That is, while we should acknowledge that technologies intervene our lifeworld and constitute our thinking and moralizing ways, we also need to break away from technological trivialities to think about and pursue long-term moral goals.

On the Source of Theory of Autonomous Technology

The Alienation and Poeticizing of Technology

Development of Science and Technology and the Process of the Liberation of Humankind——New Thoughts Based on Engels' "Dialectics of Nature"

An Analysis on Marx's Thought about Technology and Human Nature

Analysis of the theory of alternative technology

Ecological Marxism: the Conception of Science and Technology in the Dialectical Vision

On the Theory of Young Marxist Scientific Ethics

Western Marxism's Critiques of the Social Effects of Science and Technology

Probing the Foundation of Marx's Thoughts from the Perspective of the History of Technology

Western View of Technology:Its Historical Developments and Contemporary Enlightenment

From the Ideology Criticism to the Critical Theory of Technology:Comparing the Technology Theory of H.Marcuse with that of A.Feenberg

On Two Traditions of Technological Philosophy

The Generating Background,Main Contents and Theoretical Study on Douglas Kellner's "Tech-capitalism"

On Technical Ethics of Taoism——"Tao Controlling Techniques"

Developments of Theory on Endogenous Technical Change and Its Implications

On the Lineage of State Autonomy Theory

On Autonomous Transportation Systems

How to Live a Life of One’s Own: Heidegger, Marcuse and Jonas on Technology and Alienation

Technological Mediation Theory and the Moral Suspension Problem

The Innovation of Theory and Historical Studies

On Marx's Fusion Thought between Capital and Technology