Abstract:Regenerative medicine and tissue engineering are hindered by the lack of consistent measurements and standards for the mechanical characterization of tissue and scaffolds. Indentation methods for soft matter are favored because of their compatibility with small, arbitrarily shaped samples, but contact mechanics models required to interpret data are often inappropriate for soft, viscous materials. In this study, we demonstrate indentation experiments on a variety of human biopsies, animal tissue, and engineered scaffolds, and we explore the complexities of fitting analytical models to these data. Although objections exist to using Hertz contact models for soft, viscoelastic biological materials since soft matter violates their original assumptions, we demonstrate the experimental conditions that enable consistency and comparability (regardless of arguable misappropriation). Appropriate experimental conditions involving sample hydration, the indentation depth, and the ratio of the probe size to sample thickness enable repeatable metrics that are valuable when comparing synthetic scaffolds and host tissue, and bounds on these parameters are carefully described and discussed. We have also identified a reliable quasistatic parameter that can be derived from indentation data to help researchers compare results across materials and experiments. Although Hertz contact mechanics and linear viscoelastic models may constitute oversimplification for biological materials, the reporting of such simple metrics alongside more complex models is expected to support researchers in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine by providing consistency across efforts to characterize soft matter. Impact Statement To engineer replacement tissue requires a deep understanding of its biomechanical properties. Mesoscale indentation (between micron and millimeter length scales) is well-suited to characterize tissue and engineered replacements as it accommodates small, oddly shaped samples. However, it is easy to run afoul of the assumptions for common contact models when working with biological materials. In this study, we describe experimental procedures and modeling approaches that allow researchers to take advantage of indentation for biomechanical characterization while minimizing its weaknesses.

Video Enhanced Depth-Sensing Indentation Technique for Characterizing Mechanical Behaviour of Biomaterials

In Situ Elasticity and Adhesion Measurement of Biomembrane by a Video Enhanced Depth-Sensing Indentation Technique

In Situ Nanoindentation Mechanical Property of Films by Atomic Force Microscope

Novel technique for mechanical characterization of thin polymeric tissue membrane

Development of a micro-indentation device for measuring the mechanical properties of soft materials

An New Instrument for Measuring Mechanical Compliance of Micro-Systems

A Methodology for Damage Strength Evaluation of A Single Biomimetic Microcapsule

An Optical Coherence Tomography (Oct)-Based Air Jet Indentation System For Measuring The Mechanical Properties Of Soft Tissues

Note: Nanomechanical characterization of soft materials using a micro-machined nanoforce transducer with an FIB-made pyramidal tip

A Comprehensive Review of Indentation of Gels and Soft Biological Materials

A Novel Microindenter to Assess the Mechanical Properties of Soft Materials

Mechanical characterization of biocompatible thin film materials by scanning along micro-machined cantilevers for micro-/nano-system

Spherical indentation on biological films with surface energy

Nanoindentation of Soft Biological Materials

Design and Application of the Dynamic Detection Platform for Testing the Micromechanical Properties of Agricultural Products

Nano-Indentation for Characterizing Mechanical Properties of Soft Materials

An integrated push-to-pull micromechanical device: Design, fabrication, and in-situ experiment

Optical Indentation System for Analysis of the Mechanical Properties of Tissue

Nanodiamond-based spatial-temporal deformation sensing for cell mechanics

Mechanical Characterization by Mesoscale Indentation: Advantages and Pitfalls for Tissue and Scaffolds

Automated analysis of soft material microindentation.