The accuracy comparison and the clinic value of the glomerular filtration rate estimated by equations

SUN Qian-qian,TAN Min,CHANG Hong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-6790.2010.04.009
2010-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the accuracy of Cockcroft-Gault( C-G) and simplified MDRD equations in estimating the glomerular filtration rates( GFR) in Chinese diabetes mellitus patients. Methods GFR measured by radiolabeled diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid ( 99mTc-DTPA) was used as the reference standard. Serum creatinine and body weight were used to estimate GFR ( eGFR) by C-G equation and simplified MDRD equation respectively. eGFRs were compared with measured GFR. The agreements between them were evaluated by kappa statistics. Results Two hundred and seventeen diabetes mellitus patients aged ( 56. 54 ± 13. 70) years were enrolled in this study. The body weight was( 68. 06 ±10. 85) kg and the serum creatinine was( 76. 87 ±34. 25) μmol/L. The measured GFR was( 85. 18 ± 24. 96) ml·min -1·1. 73m -2. The eGFR from C-G equation ( eGFR1) was ( 97. 04 ±37. 15) ml·min -1·1. 73m -2. The eGFR fron simplified MDRD equation ( eGFR2) was( 104. 09 ± 37. 14) ml·min -1·1. 73m -2. The median bias was-6. 47 ml·min -1·1. 73m -2 ( P) between eGFR1 and measured GFR,and was -16. 51ml·min -1 ·1. 73m -2 between eGFR2 and measured GFR. Spearman correlation analysis showed good correlation between measured GFR and eGFRs. For C-G equation,the Kappa value was 0. 554. For simplified MDRD equation,the Kappa value was 0. 646. Conclusion Compared with the reference standard,both of equations show a low accuracy. The simplified MDRD equation is better than C-G equation in estimating GFR among diabetic patients.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?