An applicability study of glomerular filtration equation in elderly patients with chronic kidney disease in China

张艳,傅辰生,王姣锋,冯欣慧,张晓丽,张振兴,肖婧,叶志斌

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.0254-9026.2014.06.009

2014-01-01

Abstract:Objective To evaluate the applicability of glomerular filtration equation in elderly patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) in China.Methods Based on measured glomerular filtration rate(mGFR)obtained with 99mTc-DTPA renal dynamic imaging method,324 elderly Chinese CKD patients were enrolled in this study.The GFR was estimated using the CG equation,calibrated CG equation,simplified MDRD equation (aMDRD),re-expressed MDRD equation (rMDRD equation),modified MDRD equation for Chinese CKD patients (cMDRD equation) and CKD epidemiology collaboration (CKD-EPI) equation.The patients were divided into high mGFR group [mGFR≥60 ml · min-1 · 1.73 m-2] and low mGFR group [mGFR＜60 ml · min-1 · 1.73 m-2].Performance in bias,accuracy,mean squared predication residual (MSPR),linear correlation,linear regression analysis,receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve and Bland Altman plot analysis of these equations were assessed in the entire population and in subgroups.Data conversion was used to further evaluate the application value of these equations.Results In the entire population,when comparing the bias and accuracy of estimated GFR (eGFR) with mGFR,the eGFR estimated by CKDEPI equation showed better results.But the agreement limits of the equations,except for the calibrated CG equation,exceeded the prior acceptable tolerances,defined as 60 ml · min-1 · 1.73 m-2 The 30％ accuracy of all the equations was lower than 70％ level.Data conversion might improve the performance.The receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve showed that the differences in maximum diagnostic accuracy among all the equations for the diagnosis of renal failure [GFR＜60 ml ·min-1 · 1.73 m-2]were not statistically significant (P＞0.05).In the high GFR level subgroup with a mGFR≥60 ml · min-1 · 1.73 m-2,CKD-EPI equation showed less bias and higher accuracy than other equations.In the low GFR level subgroup with a mGFR＜60 ml · min-1 · 1.73 m-2.simplified MDRD equation showed less bias than other equations.The 15％ accuracy of CG equation was higher than that of other equations.Conclusions None of these equations were suitable for estimating GFR in the elderly Chinese population investigated.At present,based on overall performance,especially in the high GFR level subgroup,the CKD-EPI equation may be the most accurate for estimating GFR in elderly Chinese patients with CKD.Individual choice of equations and proper data conversion should be used if necessary.