University Regulation: Between University Autonomy and State Oversight

ZHANG Ran

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-4519.2011.06.012

2011-01-01

Abstract:In the recent rise of university-student disputes,the legality of student management regulation formulated by universities often becomes a central issue.This paper explores the legal status and validity of university regulation.In nature,university regulation is self-governing rules.Universities' authority of making rules is reaffirmed by state law.At the same time,however,the exercise of university authority has to be balanced against students' rights,where state oversight has a role to play.Drawing upon relevant legal provisions and legal cases in China,the paper identifies three possible approaches of state oversight: regulation documentation requirement,student grievance or administrative review,and litigation.The paper further proposes that the state should stick to three principles in its oversight: legality standards rather than reasonableness standards,review of administrative matters instead of academic matters,and procedural review rather than substantive review.