Abstract:The goal of our research is to identify strengths and weaknesses of high school level science fair and improvements that might enhance learning outcomes based on empirical assessment of student experiences. We use the web-based data collection program REDCap to implement anonymous and voluntary surveys about science fair experiences with two independent groups-high school students who recently competed in the Dallas Regional Science and Engineering Fair and post high school students (undergraduates, 1st year medical students, and 1st year biomedical graduate students) on STEM education tracks doing research at UT Southwestern Medical Center. Herein, we report quantitative and qualitative data showing student opinions about the value of science fair. Few students in any group thought that competitive science fair (C-SF) should be required. The most common reasons given for not requiring C-SF were no enjoyment and no interest in competing. On the other hand, student attitudes towards requiring non-competitive science fair (NC-SF) were nuanced and ranged as high as 91%, increasing with student maturation, science fair experience, and STEM track. The most common reasons given for requiring NC-SF were learning scientific thinking skills and research skills. Students opposed to requiring NC-SF most frequently mentioned no enjoyment and no interest in science. Several student comments critical of the fairness of science fair led us to determine possible differences in science fair experiences depending on whether or not students received help from scientists. Those who received help from scientists had an easier time getting their research idea, more access to articles in books and magazines, and less difficulty getting resources. We discuss the idea that two different types of science fairs-competitive science fair with a performance goal orientation and non-competitive science fair with a mastery goal orientation-might be required to promote the broad goal of educating all students about science and engineering.

Evaluating Students' Science Notebooks As An Assessment Tool

Analyzing Teachers' Feedback Practices in Response to Students' Work in Science Classrooms

Impact of Computer-Based Assessments on the Science's Ranks of Secondary Students

Testing One Premise of Scientific Inquiry in Science Classrooms: Examining Students' Scientific Explanations and Student Learning

On the evaluation of systemic science education reform: Searching for instructional sensitivity

Formative Assessment Strategies by Monitoring Science Students’ Problem-Solving Skill Development

Performance-based assessment: Self-efficacy, decision-making, and problem-solving skills in learning science

Using lab notebooks to examine students' engagement in modeling in an upper-division electronics lab course

What do Science Teachers Notice in the K12 Learner’s Material Produced by State Education Department?

What happens when students reflect on their self-efficacy during a test? Exploring test experience and test outcome in science

Developing and Evaluating Instructionally Sensitive Assessments in Science

Multimodal Tasks to Assess English Learners and Their Peers in Science

Measuring Students’ Ability to Engage in Scientific Inquiry: A New Instrument to Assess Data Analysis, Explanation, and Argumentation

Assessing Teachers’ Classroom Management Competency: A Case Study of the Classroom Assessment Scoring System–Secondary

Interactive Notebooks Improve Students' Understanding of Developmental Neurobiology, Attitudes Toward Research, and Experimental Design Competency in a Lecture-Based Neuroscience Course

Student-generated reading questions: diagnosing student thinking with diverse formative assessments

Improving Science Achievement—Is It Possible? Evaluating the Efficacy of a High School Chemistry and Physics Project-Based Learning Intervention

Imagining, designing, and interpreting experiments: Using quantitative assessment to improve instruction in scientific reasoning

Lessons from a Large-Scale Assessment: Results from Free Response Pre- and Post-testing in Electricity and Magnetism

High school science fair: Student opinions regarding whether participation should be required or optional and why

Improving students' academic achievement and attitude in science through comprehensive evaluation