Comparison and Analysis of Schwartz Formula Appraisal of Glomerular Filtration Rate and 99Tcm-Dtpa Clearance

张俊,曹琦,徐虹

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-5501.2010.03.008

2010-01-01

Abstract:Objective The reliable measurement of glomerular filtration rate(GFR) is of great importance in clinical practice and research.The usage of radionuclides has offered an alternative method of estimating GFR that avoids some of the practical disadvantages of inulin clearance.But radioisotopic method has the disadvantage of precautions being required in handling and disposing of radioactive materials and is also expensive.To circumvent the practical difficulties of formal measurement of clearance,several prediction formulas have been published.The most common usage in children and adolescents is the Schwartz formula based on the serum creatinine level.The aim of this study was to identify an adequate measurement of GFR in pediatric clinical practice.Methods Children with chronic kidney disease from Children′s Hospital of Fudan University from April 2002 to December 2006 were collected.99Tcm-DTPA clearance(mGFR) was measured as GFR marker in patients with different kidney disease.At the same time estimated GFR(eGFR) was calculated via the equation developed from Schwartz formula according to serum creatinine level.eGFRs were compared with measured GFRs.The agreements between them were evaluated by B kappa statistics.The precision was evaluated by R2 from linear regression.The accuracy was measured by the percentage of GFR estimate within ±30%of the measured GFR(P30).Results 170 patients with CKD(100 boys and 70 girls) were enrolled into the study.The mGFR was(73.3±26.8) mL·min-1·1.73 m-2.The eGFR from Schwartz formula was(74.2 ±27.9) mL·min-1·1.73 m-2.Pearson correlation analysis showed good correlation between mGFR and eGFR(r=0.871,P 0.05).The concordance study using the Bland-Altman method showed that there was better consistency between eGFR and mGFR in CKD stage 1 to stage 2 than that in CKD stage 3 to stage 5.The over estimate of the Schwartz formula increased with GFR decreasing.Conclusions Compared with the reference standard,the Schwartz formula shows a certain degree of accuracy.In non-examination condition situation,the Schwartz formula is suitable for estimating GFR of children and adolescents.The formula remains useful for following changes of renal function in patients.