Abstract:The problem of distributive justice has been widely discussed by Western and Chinese scholarship of Marxism. This interest results from the historical transformation of the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe at the end of the 1980s, and also from the crucial transition in China beginning in the late 1970s. By conceptualizing the basic principle of distributive justice as “reward according to effort and ability,” this paper discusses the differences between liberal thought, as exemplified by John Rawls and Robert Nozick, and the ideas of Karl Marx, from basic principles to context. It deals with the concept of “private property” or even “private ownership.” In Marx's view, the principle of distributive justice is necessarily betrayed under the condition of private ownership—the capitalist exploits workers—and the solution is the replacement of private by public ownership. Ultimately, the principle of justice is replaced by the principle of beyond justice. Nozick sees private ownership as the natural result of the principle, a condition he regards as self-ownership. Rawls shares this position with Nozick, but seeks to improve its operation with “justice as fairness,” which combines the principle of justice with the principle of beyond justice. Neither Nozick nor Rawls intuits that the principle itself would be betrayed under the condition of private ownership.

Marx's Property Right Theory: In the Perspective of Modern Western Property Right Economics

The Social Construction Logic of Property Rights:A review on the property rights studies of Chinese sociologists from the perspective of game theory

Western Marxism's Theoretical Nature and Its Implications for China

The Ideality and Reality of Marx's Theory of Human Liberalization

Enlightenment Reason and Modernity: Marx’s Critical Reconstruction

An Analysis on the Nature of Chinese Land Property Rights and Its Trajectory of Reform

Marxist State Theory in a Globalized Age

The Change of the View of Private Property: The Theoretical Opportunity of Marx's Transcendence of Philosophical Communism

From Principle to Context: Marx versus Nozick and Rawls on Distributive Justice

Property between Natural and Acquired Right

On the Study of the Property-right Reform of State-owned Enterprises

Comparison of Marx′s Political Economics and Western Economics

Marx's Theory of World History:Interpretive Framework for China's Path

The Theoretical Prospect in the Age of Rights

On Karl Marx's Early Economic Study from the Perspective of Doctrinal History

How to Understand the Reestablishing Individual Ownership of Marx and Engels

Comparative Research between Marx' and Western Theories on International Trade

MARXIAN WEALTH-CREATION THEORY AND ITS REALISTIC SIGNIFICANCE

Multiple Property Right, Substantivism and Capital Theory:An historical case study of water rights for Shanxi provinces

Marx’s rent theory revisited? Landed property, nature and value

Marx's Achievements in His Criticism of Proudhon——an Analysis on the Significance of The Poverty of Theory