Discussion on “Modelling efficiency of fluid viscous dampers positioning for increasing tall buildings' Resilience to earthquakes induced structural vibrations” by Sharma et al., Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering 173 (2023) 108108

Vaibhav Sharma,Dhiraj Raj,M. Bharathi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soildyn.2024.108458
IF: 4
2024-01-01
Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering
Abstract:Sharma et al. (2023) explored the effect of installing fluid viscous dampers (FVDs) in a building at various locations in different combinations and orientations to mitigate the vibrations induced by an earthquake. The original study was conducted for a G+20 storied building subjected to dead, live, floor, wall, and seismic loads. We appreciate the efforts made by the authors to conduct this study. However, after conducting a critical review of the original manuscript, it has been observed that Sharma et al. (2023) have severely underestimated the depth of the research topic and are misleading the readers with counterfeit technical content. It appears that the study was performed without any due diligence. Consequently, the original manuscript has teemed with typographical errors, incorrect technical terminology, uncited figures, unreasonable parameter values & units, misinterpreting findings, and misleading discussions lacking conclusive results. Hence, we would like to highlight the different aspects of this article and draw the attention of the readers of Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering through a detailed section-wise discussion.
geosciences, multidisciplinary,engineering, geological
What problem does this paper attempt to address?