The local politics of community safety: local policy for local people?

Matt Follett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46692/9781847429575.006

2006-07-05

Abstract:Social Policy Review provides students, academics and all those interested in welfare issues with detailed analyses of progress and change in areas of major interest during the past year.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Community Safety and Social Policy

Daniel Gilling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/a:1013195320449

2001-01-01

European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research

Abstract:This article examines community safety policy. In many countries community safety has become a replacement discourse for situational crime prevention, although in some countries such as the UK, it too is threatened with replacement by the narrower concerns of crime reduction. Community safety represents the apparent merging of the concerns of criminal justice and social policy, specifically over questions of social inclusion and exclusion. Focusing in the main upon UK policy, but also drawing upon experience elsewhere, this article scrutinises the policy of community safety, arguing that while it offers an inclusionary vision of crime control, its practice may be something rather different. More specifically, and in common with the trajectory of much advanced liberal social policy, in practice community safety may have an exclusionary effect. Thus, while community safety may represent the convergence of social and criminal justice policies, it does so on neo‐liberal rather than welfare liberal terms. It also means that community safety has a closer connection to policies of punitive sovereignty – particularly sentencing policies of mass incarceration – than might often be assumed.

criminology & penology
The New Local Governance of Community Safety in England and Wales

Tim Hope

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3138/cjccj.47.2.369

2005-04-01

Abstract:This article provides an overview and assessment, since 1997, of the "New Labour" government's reforms and policies of crime prevention and community safety in England and Wales. It reviews developments since the Crime and Disorder Act, 1998, and assesses the impact of the government's Crime Reduction Strategy and its campaign against antisocial behaviour. The argument is that, in its zeal to reduce crime through its "modernization" agenda, applied to public service delivery, and the consequent emphasis on performance in the reduction of crime, the government is neglecting the institution-building task of constituting a new security governance in the community. This neglect may have led to a rise in insecurity in society, fostered by a heightened anxiety about disorder. This trend seems set to continue with the government's approach to police reform. And although an emergent agenda of "civil renewal" holds out some promise for policies that recognize the role of citizens in the co-production of community safety, there are also dangers of reinforcing the insecurity of the disadvantaged, who have limited access to the social capital required for participation.

criminology & penology
Community safety and the quest for security: Holding back the dynamics of social exclusion

Adam Crawford

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01442879808423759

1998-12-01

Policy Studies

Abstract:This paper casts a deliberately critical eye over the government's ‘community safety'proposals as outlined in the UK Crime and Disorder Act 1998, their philosophical origins, their ambiguities and their potential for social exclusion. After an evaluation of some specific proposals in the Act, the paper goes on to suggest that community safety elements within the Act and associated policy initiatives embody three principal dynamics, namely appeals to community, managerialism and inter‐organisational partnerships. Within and between these dynamics lie deep ambiguities and conflicts, which may encourage, rather than hold back, the dynamics of social exclusion. It is argued that the government's proposals — under the influence of a certain brand of communitarian thought — display much confusion as to how ‘communities’ can contribute to the construction of social order. Moreover, the notion of community collides with existing social fragmentation and the commodificalion of security, which may fuel exclusionary elements of community safety practice. The paper goes on to consider the existence of important tensions between the managerialist preoccupations of policy and the rhetoric of ‘partnerships’, which pervade community safety. These can serve to undermine the intentions of legislators. Within the dynamics of crime prevention practice and appeals to ‘community’ there are dangers that ‘security differentials’ become increasingly significant characteristics of wealth and status. For community safety to hold back the dynamics of social exclusion, both government and local community safety practitioners will need to foster the conditions in which partnerships can flourish and to nurture forms of co‐operation, rooted in mutual acceptance of difference and inter‐organisational trust.

public administration
Local government policymaking environment for Health in All Policies: a case study research investigation

Kara Lilly,Suzanne Robinson,Linda A. Selvey,Jonathan Hallett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09581596.2024.2334364

2024-05-09

Critical Public Health

Abstract:The local level of government is identified as being well placed to address the determinants of health due to their flatter governance structure and proximity to the community. Research has identified multiple factors that influence local governments to act on these health determinants, although few have applied theories of the policy process to understand the policymaking environment. Using two Australian local government case study sites, we explored the policymaking environment regarding policy decisions to address health determinants using the lens of four theories of the policy process. We conducted 20 interviews and one focus group with elected members and staff in local government, along with an analysis of 12 policy documents and participation in a policy reference group. Following thematic analysis, 13 factors influencing policy addressing health determinants were identified, mostly confirming previous research from within Australia and globally. New themes have emerged regarding the limited range of policy actors involved and the lack of advocacy, particularly by community or media, who have an identified influence over decision-making in a local government context. Applying theories of the policy process also demonstrates how they can be used to add meaning to the interconnectedness of influences in unique local government policymaking environments.

public, environmental & occupational health,social sciences, biomedical
The Politics of Studentification and `(un)balanced' Urban Populations: Lessons for Gentrification and Sustainable Communities?

Darren Smith

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0042098008097108

2008-01-01

Urban Studies

Abstract:This paper explores the politics of studentification in the UK. It is argued that there is a paradox between New Labour's vision of sustainable communities and the geographical effects of the promotion of higher education—in a similar vein to policies to generate `positive' gentrification. This contention hinges on the absence of a national policy on the supply of student housing, which dictates how enlarged student populations should be integrated into established communities, or dispersed to other parts of towns and cities. It is asserted that the lack of government policy and the incapacity of institutional actors to intervene or regulate the residential geographies of students are yielding `unbalanced' populations. This is a factor in the rise of studentification and the fragmentation of established communities. Ironically, some activists argue these `lost' communities signified lucid exemplars that the sustainable communities policy seeks to engender. These new geographies also obscure the positives of a student population and may foster resentment and conflict between students and established residents. More specifically, the paper illustrates how debates of planning and housing legislation are integral for addressing the challenges of studentification. The paper concludes by considering some possible lessons of studentification for mitigating the negatives of gentrification.
Governance and Governmentality in Community Participation: The Shifting Sands of Power, Responsibility and Risk

Steve Rolfe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s1474746417000410

2017-10-30

Social Policy and Society

Abstract:Community participation has become an essential element of government policy around the globe in recent decades. This move towards ‘government through community’ has been presented as an opportunity for citizens to gain power and as a necessary part of the shift from government to governance, enabling states and communities to tackle complex problems in tandem. However, it has also been critiqued as an attempt to shift responsibility from the state onto communities. Using evidence from detailed case studies, this article examines the implementation of Localism in England and Community Empowerment in Scotland. The findings suggest a need for a more nuanced analysis of community participation policy, incorporating risk alongside responsibility and power, as well as considering the agency of communities and the local state. Furthermore, understanding the constraints on community participation is key, particularly in terms of the enveloping impacts of austerity and state retrenchment.

social work,social issues
Local Policy Choice: Theory and Empirics

William H. Hoyt,John Douglas Wilson,David Robert Agrawal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3545542

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper critically surveys the growing literature on the policy choices of local governments. We cover both selected theoretical and empirical analyses of the effects of fiscal decentralization on mobility, spillovers, fiscal externalities, and economic outcomes, including economic growth. Various reasons underlying local policy interactions are identified, including fiscal competition, bidding for firms, yardstick competition, fiscal spillovers, and Tiebout sorting. Their varying implications for local economic outcomes and welfare are emphasized. We discuss theoretically what parameters should be estimated to determine the nature of competition among local governments and how the policy outcomes emerging from this competition are affected by the presence of constraints imposed by higher-level governments. In our review of the empirical literature, we identify key issues that arise in the empirical estimation of strategic interactions among local governments and we highlight recent quasi-experimental evidence that has attempted to identify the mechanism at work. A synthesis model, containing multiple mechanisms and fiscal instruments, is employed to help resolve several puzzles and provide guidance for future research.
Remaking Local Governance through Community Participation? The Case of the UK Community Waste Sector

David Luckin,Liz Sharp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0042098042000226966

2004-07-01

Urban Studies

Abstract:This article explores the role played by community sector organisations in terms of community participation and local governance. It focuses on organisations concerned with waste reduction, reuse and recycling-community waste projects. The current UK government has high expectations of the potential and actual role of the community sector in service delivery. To indicate how these expectations might be fulfilled, the article employs the local governance perspective and reviews claims made for the role played by the community sector in governance processes. The local linkages of community waste projects are then assessed through a 'policy-action' continuum. The article concludes that community waste projects provide significant opportunities for volunteer involvement in their activities. They also have significant impacts on waste governance, through service delivery and participation in related policy processes. However, suggestions that community sector organisations can represent the wishes of local people in policy processes should be treated with caution.

environmental studies,urban studies
Localism in Practice: Investigating Citizen Participation and Good Governance in Local Government Standards of Conduct

Alan Lawton,Michael Macaulay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.12161

IF: 8.144

2013-12-23

Public Administration Review

Abstract:This article examines how, against a background of localism endorsed by the 2010 coalition government in the United Kingdom, a key component of local integrity and governance was fundamentally altered. The Localism Act 2011 abolished the English local integrity framework, which relied on the participation of local citizens in the policy making and implementation of local government standards of conduct. The article utilizes Henrik Bang's concepts of “expert citizen” and “everyday maker” to explore citizen participation in local standards committees. Using a case study approach, the article demonstrates how standards committees shaped processes and practices in the local governance of integrity. The authors argue that standards committees were crucial in promoting local participation and enhancing good governance.

public administration
Rethinking Community Research

David Studdert,Valerie Walkerdine

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-51453-0

2016-01-01

Abstract:This book sheds new light on the complex inter-relations that make up class, power, local history and space. It turns community thinking on its head by understanding community not as an object but as a relational process with sociality at its core. Based on fieldwork from one market town and the work of Hannah Arendt, it demonstrates how a new approach to social practices can illuminate our understanding of commonality and communal being. Whilst community has become both a much-derided and much-touted term, this thought-provoking work shows that it is at the heart of social process. It will appeal to researchers of sociology, social policy, politics, public health and geography, as well as those involved in public policy design and implementation.
Increasing public participation and influence in local decision-making to address social determinants of health: a systematic review examining initiatives and theories

Susan Baxter,Amy Barnes,Caroline Lee,Rebecca Mead,Mark Clowes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03003930.2022.2081551

2022-06-15

Local Government Studies

Abstract:Creating conditions to empower local people is an important determinant of health, and crucial in addressing health inequity. Yet, experimentation with initiatives to support public participation at a local level is threatened by enduring global economic instability. A better understanding of how different participatory approaches might address the social determinants of health would support future prioritisation of actions and investment.We reviewed recent literature and theories on initiatives to increase peoples' influence in local decision-making and on social determinants of health. Our synthesis found little detail about the form and function of initiatives, but diverse factors deemed influential in achieving outcomes. Studies highlighted that pressure on resources undermines individual and community capacities to participate, and requires organisational leaders to think/act differently.Suggested priorities for local governance are: supporting capabilities and relationships between organisations and communities; creating safe and equitable spaces for interaction and knowledge-sharing; and changing institutional culture.

public administration,political science,regional & urban planning
Local policy-making within the multilevel system: A study of governance in peripheral(ised) medium-sized cities undergoing socio-economic transformation in Saxony, Germany and Lower Silesia, Poland

Rafał Gajewski,Robert Knippschild

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00420980231221085

2024-01-29

Urban Studies

Abstract:Urban Studies, Ahead of Print. Our motivation for undertaking this research was to verify the scope and results of public policies aimed at supporting peripheralised medium-sized cities, and to check how these policies have been perceived by stakeholders within these cities. We selected the Polish-German borderland as a case region for this, primarily due to a particular concentration of cities experiencing the detrimental effects of socio-economic transformation. These are also cities exposed to the consequences of radicalising political discourse. We chose two pairs of cities comparable to centres behind the border: Bautzen and Görlitz (located in East Saxony), as well as Zgorzelec and Jelenia Góra (the western part of Lower Silesia). We assumed peripheralisation, left-behind places and multilevel governance to be the theoretical frameworks to capture the dynamics of processes taking place within such peripheral(ised) medium-sized cities. Our main research objective was to investigate the way the public authorities have been navigating their respective paths within the multi-level urban development / regional policy systems. The main conclusion of the research is the low institutional capacity among the public authorities in the given cities to allow them to be able to reverse negative trends.

environmental studies,urban studies
Local co‐production in safety service provision: The case of Surf Life Saving in New South Wales

Owen Hogan,Brian Dollery,Michael A. Kortt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8454.12373

2024-07-14

Australian Economic Papers

Abstract:Beaches are iconic in Australian culture. However, coastal areas are intrinsically hazardous, given the nature of recreational beach activities. The need for beach regulation and safety services has spawned a vast network of voluntary life‐saving clubs across Australia that operate collaboratively with local government and volunteers. In this paper, we examine the operation of Surf Life Saving New South Wales (SLSNSW) through the analytical lens of local co‐production. We argue that the effectiveness of SLSNSW can be mainly ascribed to the efficacious manner in which SLSNSW, local councils and volunteers have been combined to generate beach safety services.

economics
Bringing lay knowledge into place-making? A critical exploration of community review panels in London and Southeast England

Lucy Earle

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09654313.2024.2305188

2024-01-24

European Planning Studies

Abstract:This article serves as the first academic inquiry into the establishment and functioning of community review panels (CRPs) in England. CRPs are an innovation in public participation in planning. The first CRP was established in 2018 to operate within the boundaries of the Old Oak and Park Royal Development Corporation (OPDC) in West London. It was set up to mirror the workings of a Design Review Panel, with people selected to serve on the CRP for their local knowledge and ability to participate in substantive discussions. CRPs are now active in six areas of London and Southeast England, predominantly in locations experiencing significant development or regeneration. The article is based on analysis of primary interview and observation data, grey literature on CRPs, and a review of academic and policy debates on public participation and lay knowledge. It explores the potential for CRPs to provide meaningful input into planning and place-making. It concludes that well-managed panels can make meaningful contributions to the development control process, but could be more effectively employed in broader place-making. Both outcomes are contingent on local planners' willingness and ability to serve as brokers of different types of knowledge, testing lay and expert perspectives alongside each other.

environmental studies,urban studies,regional & urban planning,geography
From public issues to personal troubles: individualising social inequalities in health within local public health partnerships

Rebecca Mead,Miranda Thurston,Daniel Bloyce

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09581596.2020.1763916

2020-05-20

Critical Public Health

Abstract:This paper explores public health policy implementation through partnership working at the local level by examining how local actors from public health, and the wider workforce make sense of and work on social inequalities in health. An ethnographic case study was used to examine policy implementation in one local strategic partnership in north-west England during a period of significant resource constraint. Semi-structured interviews were the primary method of data generation. Sensitising concepts from figurational sociology were used to develop a theoretical account of how local policy implementation directed at narrowing social inequalities in health tended to give rise to relatively fragmented and short-term services, projects and practices, which focused on lifestyle factors and behaviour change. Theorising partnership work as figurations goes some way to explaining the apparent paradox among participants who expressed a relatively detached appreciation of wider social influences, alongside emotional involvement in their work. This process of individualisation explains how local professionals tended to conceptualise health inequality and the social determinants of health as personal troubles. Individualisation meant that the social reality of working in partnerships on difficult issues was simplified. Thus, any scope for working on the social determinants of health tended to be overlooked. The extent to which this was intentional or a matter of struggling to see opportunities, or a mixture of the two, was difficult to discern. Although the policy landscape has changed, the findings give some insight into understanding how local collaborative processes reproduce local public health work underpinned by lifestyle choices.

public, environmental & occupational health,social sciences, biomedical
Doing the right thing? value conflicts and community policing

Carina O’Reilly

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10439463.2022.2071423

2022-05-07

Abstract:Research on police legitimacy and public confidence underlines the importance of the police demonstrating moral alignment with the communities they serve. However, less attention is given to conflict between values, either within communities or between communities and the police. This study explores value conflicts in community or neighbourhood policing from a perspective of political realism, which suggests that such conflicts are inevitable and can only be resolved in temporary and contingent ways. It does so through a case study of neighbourhood policing, seen through local ward panel meetings, in one London borough. In total, 33 semi-structured interviews with 43 participants were undertaken, and seven hours of observations. This paper identifies four value-based conflicts that emerged through the meetings, and shows how neighbourhood police officers were able to provisionally resolve them, thus supporting confidence and legitimacy. However, it also shows how austerity has put this capacity at risk, both operationally, and through a receding of confidence as an organisational priority, with potential long-term consequences for public confidence in the police. With global protests such as Black Lives Matters, and anti-lockdown demonstrations, underlining the importance of public confidence and legitimacy to police organisations across the world, this paper adds to the evidence on the capacity of community policing to support this, offers a new perspective to understand the role of values in policing, and discusses the policy implications.

criminology & penology
Situating the local in global cultural policy

Abigail Gilmore,Leila Jancovich,David Stevenson,Victoria Durrer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09548963.2019.1644780

2019-08-08

Cultural Trends

Abstract:From the growth of city regions to the calls for more localism, engaging with "the local" has become an increasingly important part of cultural policy rhetoric in many countries (UCLG, <a href="#">2019</a> UCLG (United Cities and Local Government). (2019). Culture 21. 6 June 2019. Retrieved from <a class="ext-link" href="http://www.agenda21culture.net">http://www.agenda21culture.net</a> <a class="google-scholar" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=UCLG+%28United+Cities+and+Local+Government%29.+%282019%29.+Culture+21.+6+June+2019.+Retrieved+from+http%3A%2F%2Fwww.agenda21culture.net">[Google Scholar]</a>; UNESCO, <a href="#">2013</a> UNESCO. (2013). The Creative Economy Report: Widening Local Development Pathways. New York: UNESCO. <a class="google-scholar" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=UNESCO.+%282013%29.+The+Creative+Economy+Report%3A+Widening+Local+Development+Pathways.+New%C2%A0York%3A+UNESCO.">[Google Scholar]</a>). Yet despite apparent recognition that the practices of culture are always situated (and hence local), contemporary cultural policy research tends to privilege the national or international as the primary site at which cultural policy is enacted and thus, can be reformed (Durrer, Miller, & O'Brien, <a href="#">2018</a> Durrer, V., Miller, T., & O'Brien, D. (2018). The Routledge Handbook of Global Cultural Policy. London: Routledge. <a class="google-scholar" href="http://scholar.google.com/scholar_lookup?hl=en&publication_year=2018&author=V.+Durrer&author=T.+Miller&author=D.+O%E2%80%99Brien&title=The+Routledge+Handbook+of+Global+Cultural+Policy">[Google Scholar]</a>). For all of its increasing use, "the local" remains abstract, seemingly deployed to legitimate activity that is of debatable benefit to the places and practices imagined by its invocation.

cultural studies,social sciences, interdisciplinary
Participative Urban Renewal? Disability, Community, and Partnership in New Labour's Urban Policy

Claire Edwards

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1068/a39199

2008-07-01

Abstract:In recent years there has been significant debate regarding the potential of participatory forms of governance to engage with diverse groups and the ‘politics of difference’. This paper explores these debates in the context of disabled people's engagement in urban policy processes, as an arena in which participative imperatives have become manifest under the UK's New Labour government. Drawing on a case study of a Single Regeneration Budget partnership, I argue that there are significant limits to disabled people's engagement in urban policy, ranging from their perceived legitimacy and constitution as a ‘relevant public’, through to the processes of partnership in which managerialist objectives clash with participative agendas. The paper therefore raises issues about the rationale for participation and the extent to which notions of deliberative democracy are equipped to deal with issues of ‘difference’.
Cops in crisis?: ethnographic insights on a new era of politicization, activism, accountability, and change in transatlantic policing

Ross Deuchar,Vaughn J. Crichlow,Seth Wyatt Fallik

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10439463.2019.1584197

2019-02-26

Abstract:Against the complex backdrop of a post-modern era, characterised by a renewed emphasis on public accountability, oppositional social and political movements, it has been argued that traditional agents of social control have increasingly begun to experience a sense of disempowerment. Nowhere has this been more apparent than within the context of policing, where the increased influence of the mass media, social media, and newly empowered groups has led to an apparent legitimacy crisis on both sides of the Atlantic. To better understand officers’ views, attitudes, and perspectives about the changing landscape of policing, this paper reports on insights from a comparative study involving participant observation in two counties in a Southern State in the United States of America and three inner-city areas in Scotland. The observations were paired with in-depth semi-structured interviews with 18 American and 22 Scottish officers. The data suggest that officers on both sides of the Atlantic are hostile towards the increasing influence of new forms of media and digital activism. Many officers also expressed concern for declining public cooperation and perceived there to have been a general diminution of police authority and enforcement tactics. Finally, there was a general feeling of reduced officer self-legitimacy among the participants but an increased awareness of procedural justice and alternative (and more covert) enforcement strategies. The implications from these findings are discussed in terms of changing perceptions of justice, legitimacy, social ideology, and the proposed consequences for rights-based policing in the 21st Century.

criminology & penology
A health political science for health promotion

Evelyne de Leeuw,Patrick Harris,Jinhee Kim,Aryati Yashadhana

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/17579759211034418

Abstract:If health promotion as a field of change for human and ecological health is to maintain its urgency, it needs to continue building its policy credentials. This paper charts the development of policy as a concern for IUHE/IUHPE (International Union for Health Education/International Union for Health Promotion and Education) from the mid-1970s when 'health education policies' were prominent issues, to the launch of Healthy Public Policy (in the 1980s) and Health in All Policy (in the 2000s). We argue that solid conceptual and theoretical foundations exist to frame and develop the relevance and connectedness of health promotion more prominently. We start off with a brief introduction into (health) political science, and then illustrate the urgency of the argument with three case studies. The first takes a critical realist perspective on 'closing the gap' in Australian Indigenous populations. With recent evidence it demonstrates that the core of the policymaking process needs to re-align itself with an Indigenous narrative. The second case study reviews the politics of healthy urban planning and health equity in cities. Taking a critical theory institutionalist view, the case describes how the political and narrative parallels between urban theory and health equity have gone underexplored. With an explicit gaze to connect the two, the field could become a large and influential driver of enhanced health promotion and public health policy. The third case describes the languages, policy frames, and distinctions, in four urban/health paradigms. It shows that unconscious policy and practice bias exists in policy priorities and processes. We conclude with observations and recommendations on the role of health promotion as a conceptual realm and field of activity. We show that all health promoters should be aware of the political nature of their enterprise. Tools and analyses exist to help further action.

The local politics of community safety: local policy for local people?

Community Safety and Social Policy

The New Local Governance of Community Safety in England and Wales

Community safety and the quest for security: Holding back the dynamics of social exclusion

Local government policymaking environment for Health in All Policies: a case study research investigation

The Politics of Studentification and `(un)balanced' Urban Populations: Lessons for Gentrification and Sustainable Communities?

Governance and Governmentality in Community Participation: The Shifting Sands of Power, Responsibility and Risk

Local Policy Choice: Theory and Empirics

Remaking Local Governance through Community Participation? The Case of the UK Community Waste Sector

Localism in Practice: Investigating Citizen Participation and Good Governance in Local Government Standards of Conduct

Rethinking Community Research

Increasing public participation and influence in local decision-making to address social determinants of health: a systematic review examining initiatives and theories

Local policy-making within the multilevel system: A study of governance in peripheral(ised) medium-sized cities undergoing socio-economic transformation in Saxony, Germany and Lower Silesia, Poland

Local co‐production in safety service provision: The case of Surf Life Saving in New South Wales

Bringing lay knowledge into place-making? A critical exploration of community review panels in London and Southeast England

From public issues to personal troubles: individualising social inequalities in health within local public health partnerships

Doing the right thing? value conflicts and community policing

Situating the local in global cultural policy

Participative Urban Renewal? Disability, Community, and Partnership in New Labour's Urban Policy

Cops in crisis?: ethnographic insights on a new era of politicization, activism, accountability, and change in transatlantic policing

A health political science for health promotion