Fuzzy approach and possibility to solve uncertainty weaknesses in conventional quantitative risk assessment
Seddik, Hellas Mohamed,Rachid, Chaib
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00500-023-07960-0
IF: 3.732
2023-03-10
Soft Computing
Abstract:The disadvantage of the methods used in dependability and especially the QRA (Quantitative Risk Assessment) method is that of data imperfection and the lack of robustness in the results (subjective estimation of frequencies and consequences effects of accident scenarios). This subjectivity results from several factors, in particular, the high number of components in the system studies, connections and structural interactions, and functional dependencies between the components including operating conditions. Also, physical factors and environmental influence the state and functioning of the system. All these factors alternate the credibility and perfection of data as well as security analysis results. Although the QRA method is effective, its application is very costly in terms of time and effort, which requires competent specialists. It is right that several aspects are not well supported by conventional QRA. Paving the way for further improvements and suggesting soft computing approaches using fuzzy sets and logic although various other approaches can be adopted such as fuzzy probability theory approach. A good review of the QRA approach in various fields is also appreciated as the availability and quality of the data restrict the objectivity and effectiveness of QRA and secondly the results of QRA either the steps taken are qualitative or quantitative are associated with uncertainty or impreciseness and compel to adopt soft computing approach. Four types of uncertainties are covered: Uncertainty associated with input parameters, stochastic/ontological uncertainty, Assessment and reduction in risk and modeling of dangerous effects. The uncertainties inherent in QRA approach are dealt with using tools from the theory of fuzzy sets and that of possibility and helpful in flexible solutions allowing for adaptive risk management.
computer science, artificial intelligence, interdisciplinary applications