Abstract:Background: The increasing availability of massive administrative data sets linking postsecondary enrollees with postcollege earnings records has stimulated a wealth of new research on the returns to college and has accelerated state and federal efforts to hold institutions accountable for students' labor market outcomes. Many of these new research and policy efforts rely on state databases limited to postsecondary enrollees who work in the same state postcollege, with limited information regarding family background and precollege ability. Objectives: In this article, we use recent waves of data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997 to provide new, nationally representative, nonexperimental estimates of the returns to degrees, as well as to assess the possible limitations of single-state, administrative data-based estimates. Research design: To do this, we explore the sensitivity of estimated returns to college, by testing different sample restrictions, inclusion of different sets of covariates, and alternative ways of treating out-of-state earnings to approximate the real-world limitations of state administrative databases. Results: We find that failure to control for measures of student ability leads to upward bias, while limiting the sample to college enrollees only leads to an understatement of degree returns. On net, these two biases roughly balance out, suggesting that administrative data-based estimates may reasonably approximate true returns. Conclusions: We conclude with a discussion of the relative advantages and disadvantages of survey versus administrative data for estimating returns to college as well as implications for research and policy efforts based upon single-state administrative databases.

High school employment, high school curriculum, and post-school wages

Part-Time Employment in High School and Its Effect on Academic Achievement

Changes in Economic Return to Schooling and Employment Rate with the Expansion of Higher Education

The effects of employment, unemployment and further education upon the work values of school leavers

Student Employment and Education: A Meta-Analysis

Career education that works: an economic analysis using the British Cohort Study

The Value of a High School GPA

Academic Performance and Part-Time Employment among High School Seniors

Returns to Education: The Causal Effects of Education on Earnings, Health, and Smoking

More than Sheepskin: A Natural Experiment on College and Earnings

Academic Achievement and Part-Time Employment of High School Students

The Labor Market Value of Higher Education: Now and in the Future

Heterogeneous Returns to College over the Life Course

Educational choice, initial wage and wage growth

The Returns to Education: Microeconomics

The Returns of a Community College Education: Evidence From the National Education Longitudinal Survey

Estimating Returns to College Attainment: Comparing Survey and State Administrative Data-Based Estimates

The Nonmarket Benefits of Education and Ability

Improving the Accuracy of Estimated Returns to Education in China- Based on Employment Rate, Career Length, and Income Growth

Supplementary Education at College and Its Consequences for Individuals’ Labor Market Outcomes in the United States

Taking the long view of adolescent work quality