Discussion of Classical Phosphate Extraction Schemes to Identify Speciation in (Hydro-) Thermochemically Treated Sewage Sludge

Gero C. Becker,Andrea Kruse
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acssuschemeng.3c03720
IF: 8.4
2023-10-25
ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering
Abstract:Understanding phosphate speciation in thermally treated sewage sludge is important for fertilization and technological phosphate recovery. Different extraction schemes including the soil phosphate-related Hedley fractionation and the freshwater sediment-related SMT protocol are widely used in the literature to describe (hydro-) thermochemically provoked changes in sewage sludge phosphate species. The results are usually directly linked to the solubility and bioavailability. This work discusses the applicability and interpretation of these two most widely used schemes in the case study of a thermochemically treated aluminate-rich municipal sewage sludge. The studied conversion technologies are low- and high-temperature hydrothermal conversions (190 and 250 °C, respectively) and fast as well as slow pyrolysis (15 s to 7.5 min retention time, 500 °C reaction temperature). Hydrothermal treatment clearly shows a change from phosphate-related to Fe- and Al-ion associations to Ca phosphate species in both extraction schemes, while this is seen to a lesser extent after pyrolysis. Phosphate fractions, which can be believed to be plant-available, are only shown in the Hedley fractionation. They disappear during hydrothermal treatment, probably following desorption mechanisms similar to effects mimicked by common extraction tests for plant-available soil phosphate. The sequential nature of the Hedley fractionation also revealed a reduced solubility of pyrolytically altered phosphates in dilute mineral acid, which is not seen in the SMT protocol to the same extent. Therefore, the use of SMT protocol results to compare changes after hydrothermal and pyrolytic treatment can lead to the wrong assumption that the resulting phosphate fractions are similar in nature, while at the same time, directly plant-available phosphate fractions are neglected.
chemistry, multidisciplinary,engineering, chemical,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?