Abstract:Universities are increasingly regarded as key actors in the new 'knowledge economy', with requirements to produce market-oriented knowledge and engage in commercialization. This is of particular significance in the biomedical field, reflecting the perceived gap between success in terms of scientific discoveries and its transformation into products. The dominant discourse attributes this situation to 'blocks' in the translational pathway from 'bench to bedside', leading to policies to 'reengineer' the research enterprise. This study examines a pilot initiative established by the UK's Medical Research Council (MRC). This involved employing a change agent (Research Translator) supported by a small amount of translational funding to promote the culture and practice of translational research at a university/hospital site in England. An ethnographically informed case study involving semi-structured and open exploratory interviews, observation and document review, was conducted in 2008. Analysis and interpretation were informed by Bourdieu's logic of practice applied to science. The requirements of translational research promoted by the Research Translator and its sources of capital (authority, prestige etc) were largely congruent with the 'field' of clinical science. In contrast, translational research diverged from perceptions of 'legitimate' science and requirements for capital accumulation held by the majority of basic scientists who often described this research as 'high risk' and were resistant to the Research Translator's advice. However some differences in motivations and practices were identified within groups of scientists associated with career stage, work environment and specialty. We argue that there are convergent and divergent forces that influence scientists' readiness to adopt a market-oriented translational research model and in turn facilitate or constrain the effectiveness of a knowledge broker. We also identify ways in which current structures and policies continue to promote a continuum of forms of knowledge production, thus challenging notions of a linear shift.

How I'm supporting other researchers who have moved to Lithuania

How bioinformatics led one scientist home to Lithuania

Researchers in Hungary raise fears of brain drain after 'body blow' EU funding suspension

I fell out of love with the lab, and in love with business

ECR Spotlight – Sulayman Lyons

Barriers to attracting the best researchers: perceptions of academics in economics and physics in three European countries

Explaining Scientists’ Plans for International Mobility from a Life Course Perspective

Want a new job in science? Six charts to help you land it

Introducing new group leaders: Sahar Melamed

Crossing disciplinary boundaries: An ethnographic exploration of academic publishing invitations

Should We All be Scientists? Re-thinking Laboratory Research as a Calling

Physiologists as medical scientists: An early warning from the German academic system

A researcher-exchange programme made me a better doctor at home and abroad

An interview with Ykä Helariutta

Implementing 'translational' biomedical research: convergence and divergence among clinical and basic scientists

Malte Gersch

Firmly Planted, Always Moving

Geographical and institutional motives for mobility of researchers in science-based post-socialist city

Translating between science and politics as a government adviser

What's the state of hiring researchers in science? Share your insights with Nature

Focus on People and the Science Will Follow: Motivating Forces for Professional Movement in Stem Cell Research