Academic-Industrial Collaborations: Merging Paths to Thrive

Hongli Bao,Karla Bravo-Altamirano,Zachary Buchan,Pablo J Cabrera,Sarah J Ryan,Joshua J Roth,Fernando Sartillo-Piscil,Yasuhiro Sawai,Uttam K Tambar,Cayetana Zarate

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.orglett.4c01107

IF: 5.2

2024-04-13

Organic Letters

Abstract:Org Lett . 2024 Apr 12;26(14):2669-2671. doi: 10.1021/acs.orglett.4c01107. NO

chemistry, organic

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Better Together: Catalyzing Innovation in Organic Synthesis via Academic-Industrial Consortia

Jesús Alcázar,Edward A. Anderson,Huw M. L. Davies,Rio Febrian,Christopher B. Kelly,Timothy Noël,Eric A. Voight,Cayetana Zarate,Eli Zysman-Colman,Jesús Alcázar,Timothy Noël

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.orglett.4c00192

IF: 5.2

2024-01-30

Organic Letters

Abstract:Org Lett . 2024 Jan 29. doi: 10.1021/acs.orglett.4c00192. Online ahead of print. NO

chemistry, organic
Advancing science and education through a novel collaboration platform between the University of Michigan and Peking University Health Science Center

Joseph C. Kolars,Qimin Zhan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1096/fba.2020-00128

2021-03-04

FASEB BioAdvances

Abstract:Research in China has been advancing over the past decade with increasing investments from government and private entities. Collaboration with Chinese investigators and those in the United States has also increased as reflected in the growth of scientific papers with Chinese authors. Collaborations are more commonly based on faculty-to-faculty relationships which can be challenged by institutional or governmental policies. This paper reports on an institution-to- institution collaboration, the Joint Institute for Translational and Clinical Research initiated in 2010 between the University of Michigan Medical School and Peking University Health Science Center, to enable and support collaborative faculty-initiated research. Concomitant education and training programs have also been co-developed. Beginning in 2011, 190 proposals from faculty-to-faculty partnerships have been submitted from which 59 have been selected for funding. These projects have involved over 138,000 patient subjects and resulted in 86 peer-reviewed publications to date. Pilot data has been leveraged to secure $27.3 million dollars of extramural funding outside of China. Faculty and trainee exchanges take place regularly including an annual symposium with mechanisms to link faculty who are seeking partnerships by utilizing each other's complementary strengths and resources. As the collaboration enters its second decade, both institutions believe that the model offers a unique platform to promote faculty-initiated collaborative research. Next steps include funding studies in prioritized scientific themes, and promoting access to high-quality cohorts to attract industry partners and to develop sustainable financial models.
Academia or Industry: Lessons on Choosing Career Paths─There May Be More Than One Fork in the Road Ahead

Donna G Blackmond,Marion Emmert,Donna M Huryn,Michael L Neidig,Thomas Schaub,Joseph J Topczewski,Karla Bravo-Altamirano,Zachary Buchan,Pablo J Cabrera

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.orglett.4c01099

IF: 5.2

2024-04-13

Organic Letters

Abstract:Org Lett . 2024 Apr 12;26(14):2682-2685. doi: 10.1021/acs.orglett.4c01099. NO

chemistry, organic
Emerging best strategies and capabilities for university–industry cooperation: opportunities for MSMEs and universities to improve collaboration. A literature review 2000–2023

Elizaveta Tereshchenko,Erno Salmela,Elsa Melkko,Swee King Phang,Ari Happonen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13731-024-00386-4

2024-05-08

Journal of Innovation and Entrepreneurship

Abstract:Abstract Continuous technological development, digitalization, Industry 4.0, robotization, virtualization, and related investments in new types of physical assets are imposing increasing financial and intellectual demands on micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs). While fast technological development and rapid societal change make maintenance of a successful competitive edge ever more challenging, they also offer considerable potential for differentiation. In the area of networking and outside resources, MSMEs can utilize external resources and cooperate and collaborate with higher educational institutions (HEI) to boost their innovations pipeline and develop new technologies and processes to generate commercial products/services and improve their service offering. This research explores existing highly effective university–industry collaboration (UIC) models and seeks explanations for their success by examining the literature from the point of view of establishing successful relationships, emphasizing the importance of critical drivers for success. Our work synthesizes current knowledge of best practices based on a comparative analysis of practical collaboration. In the work, we identify eight popular and successful collaboration models: research and development partnerships, internships and co-op programs, knowledge transfer programs, entrepreneurship, and incubation programs, sponsored projects and grants, joint ventures and licensing agreements, executive education, professional and student career development. Based on analysis of globally reviewed successful models, a concept for robust, productive, and extended collaboration between companies and universities is produced suitable for the Finnish context. Several practical experiences are given for robust collaboration in the current post-COVID transition and energy crisis.
Academic Medical Centers as Innovation Ecosystems: Evolution of Industry Partnership Models Beyond the Bayh-Dole Act

Patrick J Silva,Kenneth S Ramos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000002259

Abstract:Innovation ecosystems tied to academic medical centers (AMCs) are inextricably linked to policy, practices, and infrastructure resulting from the Bayh-Dole Act in 1980. Bayh-Dole smoothed the way to patenting and licensing new drugs and, to some degree, medical devices and diagnostic reagents. Property rights under Bayh-Dole provided significant incentive for industry investments in clinical trials, clinical validation, and industrial scale-up of products that advanced health care. Bayh-Dole amplified private investment in biotechnology drug development and, from the authors' perspective, did not significantly interfere with the ability of AMCs to produce excellent peer-reviewed science. In today's policy environment, it is increasingly difficult to patent and license products based on the laws of nature-as the scope of patentability has been narrowed by case law and development of a suitable clinical and business case for the technology is increasingly a gating consideration for licensees. Consequently, fewer academic patents are commercially valuable. The role of technology transfer organizations in engaging industry partners has thus become increasingly complex. The partnering toolbox and organizational mandate for commercialization must evolve toward novel collaborative models that exploit opportunities for future patent creation (early drug discovery), data exchange (precision medicine using big data), cohort assembly (clinical trials), and decision rule validation (clinical trials). These inputs contribute to intellectual property rights, and their clinical exploitation manifests the commercialization of translational science. New collaboration models between AMCs and industry must be established to leverage the assets within AMCs that industry partners deem valuable.
Collaboration Platforms in China for Translational and Clinical Research: The Partnership Between Peking University Health Science Center and the University of Michigan Medical School.

Joseph C Kolars,Weigang Fang,Kai Zheng,Amy Y Huang,Qiudan Sun,Yanfang Wang,James O Woolliscroft,Yang Ke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000001202

2017-01-01

Abstract:PROBLEM:Clinical and translational research is increasing in China, attracting faculty-to-faculty collaborations between U.S. and Chinese researchers. However, examples of successful institution-to-institution collaborations to facilitate this research are limited. The authors describe a partnership between Peking University Health Science Center (PUHSC) and the University of Michigan Medical School (UMMS) designed to enable faculty-initiated joint translational and clinical research projects. APPROACH:In 2009, UMMS leadership identified PUHSC as the most appropriate institutional partner, and the Joint Institute for Translational and Clinical Research was established in 2010. Each contributed $7 million for joint research projects in areas of mutual interest. A shared governance structure, four thematic programs (pulmonary, cardiovascular, liver, and renal diseases), three joint research-enabling cores, and processes for awarding funding have been established along with methods for collaborating and mechanisms to share data and biomaterials. OUTCOMES:As of November 2015, 52 joint faculty proposals have been submitted, and 25 have been funded. These projects have involved more than 100,000 patients in the United States and China and have generated 13 peer-reviewed publications. Pilot data have been leveraged to secure $3.3 million of U.S. extramural funding. Faculty and trainee exchanges take place regularly (including an annual symposium), and mechanisms exist to link faculty seeking collaborations. Critical determinants of success include having co-ownership at all levels with coinvestment of resources. NEXT STEPS:Each institution is committed to continuing its support with a repeat $7 million investment. Next steps include initiating studies in new clinical areas and pursuing large clinical intervention trials.
Multiphase entrepreneurship: An academic reflection

Liang-Shih Fan,Sonu Kumar,Ashin A. Sunny,Rushikesh K. Joshi,Pinak Mohapatra,Anuj S. Joshi,Qussai Marashdeh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.powtec.2024.119654

IF: 5.64

2024-03-31

Powder Technology

Abstract:Teaching, research, and service have traditionally been the common denominators of faculty professional responsibilities at academic institutions. In contrast, entrepreneurship has historically been considered separate from these responsibilities, often viewed as an aspirational goal above and beyond the standard expectations. This situation arises, in part, from the fact that most academic environments do not usually offer the conditions conducive for faculty to commercialize their ideas through entrepreneurship. Yet, integrating entrepreneurship with academic duties offers a unique opportunity to enhance the impact of one's work beyond the scholarly community, aligning well with the current public-facing and, the innovation-driven landscape of higher education. For faculty to succeed in academic entrepreneurship, balancing and harmonizing entrepreneurial goals with traditional responsibilities as members of the university is crucial. Furthermore, faculty need to understand the product market, the related tech-economic factors, the importance of industrial and academic partnerships, and the required financial and workforce support to achieve successful entrepreneurship outcomes. In this article, I illustrate that embracing entrepreneurship not only complements but also enriches traditional academic duties, offering a means to apply research in addressing real-world challenges. Speaking from personal experience, I recount how I set the goal early in my academic career to make entrepreneurship a significant part of my professional life, how this decision was informed by my research on multiphase reaction engineering, an area replete with examples of successful industrial processes, and how this guided my path forward in developing commercial processes of my own. I aim to elucidate the challenges of academic entrepreneurship through the lens of my entrepreneurial efforts. Through my journey spanning four decades, I highlight the rewards of academic entrepreneurship, including enhanced research applicability, increased funding opportunities, and the personal satisfaction of seeing one's work contribute to societal advancement. This journey, punctuated and highlighted with a multitude of opportunities, challenges, and experiences, has yielded several industrial processes, made possible by the support of strong, capable teams of creative and dedicated graduate students and post-doctoral research associates. I have also benefited considerably from the support of the Ohio State University (OSU) in matters such as patent filing, licensing, and startup spin-offs. The strength of the industrial partnerships I have played a part in forging has facilitated the potential realization of commercializing selected technologies—the ultimate goal of academic entrepreneurship. This article aims to demystify the challenges of academic entrepreneurship and inspire my academic colleagues to consider how they, too, can weave entrepreneurial endeavors into the tapestry of their professional careers. The journey of academic entrepreneurship is not only about achieving commercial success but also about synergistically enriching one's teaching and research goals with the dynamism of real-world problem-solving in ways that make a lasting impact on both academia and industry.

engineering, chemical
Collaborate, disseminate, accelerate

Vivien Marx

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41592-024-02202-z

IF: 48

2024-02-29

Nature Methods

Abstract:Collaborations between researchers and companies can progress swimmingly and teams quickly validate findings and mature methods. All too often, things can't advance and the 'Valley of Death' looms. New ways to collaborate, underpinned by computational muscle, can help.

biochemical research methods
Insights from an Industrial Collaborative Assembly Project: Lessons in Research and Collaboration

Tan Chen,Zhe Huang,James Motes,Junyi Geng,Quang Minh Ta,Holly Dinkel,Hameed Abdul-Rashid,Jessica Myers,Ye-Ji Mun,Wei-che Lin,Yuan-yung Huang,Sizhe Liu,Marco Morales,Nancy M. Amato,Katherine Driggs-Campbell,Timothy Bretl

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2205.14340

IF: 3.7

2022-05-28

Robotics

Abstract:Significant progress in robotics reveals new opportunities to advance manufacturing. Next-generation industrial automation will require both integration of distinct robotic technologies and their application to challenging industrial environments. This paper presents lessons from a collaborative assembly project between three academic research groups and an industry partner. The goal of the project is to develop a flexible, safe, and productive manufacturing cell for sub-centimeter precision assembly. Solving this problem in a high-mix, low-volume production line motivates multiple research thrusts in robotics. This work identifies new directions in collaborative robotics for industrial applications and offers insight toward strengthening collaborations between institutions in academia and industry on the development of new technologies.
Reaching across the divide: Materials Scientists interfacing with Biologists

Rachana Acharya,Roisin Meabh Owens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4mh00883a

IF: 13.3

2024-09-01

Materials Horizons

Abstract:Scientific research is becoming increasingly interdisciplinary and poses new challenges, undertakings, and prospects. In this article, we discuss the various aspects of interdisciplinarity in the developing field of organic bioelectronics. The authors represent two different fields, namely, biochemistry and materials science, and discuss their perspectives on working together in a scientifically diverse research environment. We outline today's challenges based on personal experiences and present possible solutions and hopeful opportunities for the future.

materials science, multidisciplinary,chemistry
The Alliance Between the German Cancer Research Center and Bayer: A Retrospective of an Innovative Collaboration Model

A Zuccotti,R Carretero,H Hess-Stumpp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/164_2024_726

2024-08-24

Abstract:In 2009, the German Cancer Research Center (DKFZ) and the biopharmaceutical company Bayer AG initiated an academic-industry co-discovery collaboration. The partners combined their expertise in tumor biology and drug discovery to identify and validate novel targets for cancer treatment. In the early phase of the Alliance, the focus was on target identification and validation projects. Over time, both partners realized that they could also successfully collaborate on later stages of drug discovery. As a result over the past few years, and following several contract extensions, the two partners have collaborated on several late-stage drug discovery projects. This has resulted in the achievement of several drug discovery milestones and the initiation of early clinical trials, the most recent in 2022. This success has been possible thanks to both partners' understanding of each other's needs and challenges. They jointly developed solutions to issues such as the intrinsic potential conflict of early publishing versus patent protection. Both partners also appreciated the risks involved in some of the experiments, such as starting a joint laboratory for immune-therapy with scientists from both parties working bench-to-bench. Recently, despite these successes the partners decided to terminate the Alliance, as Bayer AG wants to focus its activities on the development of its late pipeline.
Advancing Together: Celebrating Past Achievements and Embracing New Horizons at ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces

Xing Yi Ling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acsami.4c00144

IF: 9.5

2024-01-26

ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces

Abstract:ACS Appl Mater Interfaces . 2024 Jan 24;16(3):2999-3000. doi: 10.1021/acsami.4c00144. NO

materials science, multidisciplinary,nanoscience & nanotechnology
Connecting biology and organic chemistry introductory laboratory courses through a collaborative research project

Ariana L Boltax,Stephanie Armanious,Melissa S Kosinski-Collins,Jason K Pontrello

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/bmb.20871

Abstract:Modern research often requires collaboration of experts in fields, such as math, chemistry, biology, physics, and computer science to develop unique solutions to common problems. Traditional introductory undergraduate laboratory curricula in the sciences often do not emphasize connections possible between the various disciplines. We designed an interdisciplinary, medically relevant, project intended to help students see connections between chemistry and biology. Second term organic chemistry laboratory students designed and synthesized potential polymer inhibitors or inducers of polyglutamine protein aggregation. The use of novel target compounds added the uncertainty of scientific research to the project. Biology laboratory students then tested the novel potential pharmaceuticals in Huntington's disease model assays, using in vitro polyglutamine peptide aggregation and in vivo lethality studies in Drosophila. Students read articles from the primary literature describing the system from both chemical and biological perspectives. Assessment revealed that students emerged from both courses with a deeper understanding of the interdisciplinary nature of biology and chemistry and a heightened interest in basic research. The design of this collaborative project for introductory biology and organic chemistry labs demonstrated how the local interests and expertise at a university can be drawn from to create an effective way to integrate these introductory courses. Rather than simply presenting a series of experiments to be replicated, we hope that our efforts will inspire other scientists to think about how some aspect of authentic work can be brought into their own courses, and we also welcome additional collaborations to extend the scope of the scientific exploration.
Is together better? Examining scientific collaborations across multiple authors, institutions, and departments

Lovenoor Aulck,Kishore Vasan,Jevin West

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1809.04093

2018-09-11

Social and Information Networks

Abstract:Collaborations are an integral part of scientific research and publishing. In the past, access to large-scale corpora has limited the ways in which questions about collaborations could be investigated. However, with improvements in data/metadata quality and access, it is possible to explore the idea of research collaboration in ways beyond the traditional definition of multiple authorship. In this paper, we examine scientific works through three different lenses of collaboration: across multiple authors, multiple institutions, and multiple departments. We believe this to be a first look at multiple departmental collaborations as we employ extensive data curation to disambiguate authors' departmental affiliations for nearly 70,000 scientific papers. We then compare citation metrics across the different definitions of collaboration and find that papers defined as being collaborative were more frequently cited than their non-collaborative counterparts, regardless of the definition of collaboration used. We also share preliminary results from examining the relationship between co-citation and co-authorship by analyzing the extent to which similar fields (as determined by co-citation) are collaborating on works (as determined by co-authorship). These preliminary results reveal trends of compartmentalization with respect to intra-institutional collaboration and show promise in being expanded.
Science and technology collaboration platform for private SMEs and universities: A study in China

Feiyu Chen,Chong Wu,Weining Yang,Wei Zhang,Wei Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/9780784413135.051

2013-01-01

Abstract:Collaboration between industry and universities seems to have become increasingly important for industrialized countries. To realize the maximized profits through such collaboration, it is important to have a fruitful and healthy collaboration. SandT achievements collaboration platform in Wenzhou (China) is a new-fashioned form. This paper analyzes the collaboration relationship and explores the influence of collaboration on small- and medium-sized private enterprises (SMEs). Following a survey of 523 private SMEs and 61 universities, the results indicate that private SMEs can improve economic performance through the collaborations with universities on the platform. Furthermore, the economic performance of private SMEs is positively related with collaborated projects, (i.e. the more collaboration, the better economic performance). The results also reveal that SMEs choose different collaboration models on platform, which will produce different effect on economic performances of enterprises. © 2013 American Society of Civil Engineers.
Enabling creative collaboration for all levels of learning

Youngmoo E Kim,Brandon G Morton,Jeff Gregorio,David S Rosen,Kareem Edouard,Richard Vallett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1808678115

2019-02-05

Abstract:A potential path for enabling greater creativity and collaboration is through increased arts and science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) integration in education and research. This approach has been a growing discussion in US national forums and is the foundation of the science, technology, engineering, and mathematics plus arts and design (STEAM) education movement. Developing authentic artistic integrations with STEM fields (or vice versa) is challenging, particularly in higher education, where traditional disciplinary structures and incentives can impede the creation of integrated programs. Measuring and assessing the outcomes of such integration efforts can be even more challenging, since traditional metrics do not necessarily capture new opportunities created for students and faculty, and the greatest impact may occur over a long period (a career). At Drexel University, we created the Expressive & Creative Interaction Technologies (ExCITe) Center as a standalone institute to pursue and enable such transdisciplinary arts-STEM collaborations, particularly with external arts and education partners. In this perspectives paper, we highlight a range of projects and outcomes resulting from such external collaborations, including graduate research with professional artists, undergraduate student work experiences, and STEAM-based education programs for kindergarten through 12th-grade (K-12) students. While each project has its own specific objectives and outcomes, we believe that they collectively demonstrate this integrated transdisciplinary approach to be impactful and potentially transformative for all levels of learning.
Collaborative GSK-University of Strathclyde doctoral research and training programmes: Transforming approaches to industry-academia engagement

Laura C. Paterson,Philip G. Humphreys,Henry A. Kelly,William J. Kerr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drudis.2024.104162

IF: 8.369

2024-09-10

Drug Discovery Today

Abstract:A global biopharma company, GSK, and the University of Strathclyde have developed an expansive and transformative research and training partnership originating in chemistry-aligned disciplines, with subsequent extensive expansion across further areas of the company. This has opened unique approaches for the delivery of collaborative research innovations while also enhancing the professional development and learning of GSK personnel, in addition to other embedded researchers and collaborating...

pharmacology & pharmacy
Enhancing research collaboration within a large university department

Paul Michael Gilmour

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14703297.2023.2209064

IF: 2.027

2023-05-05

Innovations in Education and Teaching International

Abstract:As academic research evolves into distinct identities of specialised knowledge, institutional and paradigmatic barriers are formed between research teams, which demand enhanced research collaboration and cross-fertilisation of ideas. Drawing on the concept of cross-fertilisation, this paper adds original contributions to literature on research collaboration in three ways. First, it underlines key barriers facing academics in undertaking research. Second, it demonstrates why research collaboration helps to drive research output and enrich research cultures. Third, it offers valuable insights into technological and social initiatives supporting research collaboration. This paper reports on a study within the University of Portsmouth's School of Criminology and Criminal Justice – the UK's largest criminology department. It reveals universities must address four key issues to enhance research collaboration. These involve managing researchers' workload pressures, fostering positive research cultures, improving knowledge of and access to research and funding processes, and exploring collaborative technologies.

education & educational research
A Discussion about the Spread of “ Industry Academia Collaboration ” in Japan Based on the Text Mining Analysis of Newspaper Articles

Takehiko Koshiyama,Y. Yamaguchi,Akira Yamazaki,J. Fujimoto

Abstract:The purpose of this study is to reveal the spread of the word “industry academia collaboration” in Japan based on the text mining analysis and discuss the problems and the suggestions. As research methods, articles including industry academia collaboration were searched and collected from Yomidas Rekishikan that was a database of newspaper articles. The words appearing frequently in the articles were extracted utilizing KH Coder that was text mining software and analyzed. As a result, 960 articles were collected, and 149 words were extracted from the articles. Excepting 43 words that seemed too general, 106 words were analyzed. The words were classified into 12 clusters. It was elucidated that the important points of the articles changed into in turn, "intellectual property" in 1998, "production of products" in 1999, "technology transfer" and "school education" in 2000, "policies and budgets of governments" and "startups of enterprises" in 2002, "human resource training" in 2004, "national university corporations" in 2006, "universities" in 2008, "local region promotion" in 2009, "production of products" in 2010 and 2011, "business" in 2012 and "regenerative medicine" in 2014. As policy implications, it is suggested that the expansion of competitive research funds promoting autonomous projects by private companies and universities and the institution not demanding quick results but promoting long term activities by private companies and universities are

Business,Education

Academic-Industrial Collaborations: Merging Paths to Thrive

Better Together: Catalyzing Innovation in Organic Synthesis via Academic-Industrial Consortia

Advancing science and education through a novel collaboration platform between the University of Michigan and Peking University Health Science Center

Academia or Industry: Lessons on Choosing Career Paths─There May Be More Than One Fork in the Road Ahead

Emerging best strategies and capabilities for university–industry cooperation: opportunities for MSMEs and universities to improve collaboration. A literature review 2000–2023

Academic Medical Centers as Innovation Ecosystems: Evolution of Industry Partnership Models Beyond the Bayh-Dole Act

Collaboration Platforms in China for Translational and Clinical Research: The Partnership Between Peking University Health Science Center and the University of Michigan Medical School.

Multiphase entrepreneurship: An academic reflection

Collaborate, disseminate, accelerate

Insights from an Industrial Collaborative Assembly Project: Lessons in Research and Collaboration

Reaching across the divide: Materials Scientists interfacing with Biologists

The Alliance Between the German Cancer Research Center and Bayer: A Retrospective of an Innovative Collaboration Model

Advancing Together: Celebrating Past Achievements and Embracing New Horizons at ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces

Connecting biology and organic chemistry introductory laboratory courses through a collaborative research project

Is together better? Examining scientific collaborations across multiple authors, institutions, and departments

Science and technology collaboration platform for private SMEs and universities: A study in China

Enabling creative collaboration for all levels of learning

Collaborative GSK-University of Strathclyde doctoral research and training programmes: Transforming approaches to industry-academia engagement

Enhancing research collaboration within a large university department

A Discussion about the Spread of “ Industry Academia Collaboration ” in Japan Based on the Text Mining Analysis of Newspaper Articles