The Union of the Elementary Teaching of Science and Mathematics
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/002205a0
IF: 64.8
1870-07-01
Nature
Abstract:ATTENTION is being more and more given to the teaching of science as a means of education. The object of education may be regarded as being to help people to think for themselves; and our duty in practically educating people is two-fold; we must supply them both with the materials for thought and with the method of thinking. It is in this latter respect that the scientific education which has as yet chiefly been given appears to us to have been somewhat deficient. Yet this is the most important part; for materials for thought are supplied by nature itself, whereas the method of scientific thought and reasoning is the result of the world's progress, and to inculcate that method ought to be our chief aim. The excellence of science as a means of teaching people how to think, consists in two things: first, that the facts with which it has to deal are real tangible things, and secondly that the method of reasoning which it applies to these facts is accurate; for if, in any part of science, the accuracy of mathematical reasoning is not attained, at least we can always put down our finger distinctly on the places where it is and where it is not attained. Now the error which has been made, and which is constantly being made, in the teaching of science throughout the country, is that these accurate methods of reasoning, and these tangible facts, have been separated from one another. In our boys' schools and elsewhere (with very few exceptions), mathematics are taught wholly as applied to hypothetical cases, if even so much as that. They are thus the driest bones of method, or like a mill grinding without any corn in it. A man who learns method in this way is like a man who learns anatomy from diagrams and not from the human body itself. On the other hand the facts with which science has to deal are, with very few exceptions, almost everywhere brought forward as isolated facts, or their connection is treated in such a way that the true scientific accuracy of reasoning, by which that connection is demonstrated, is either omitted, or receives an altogether unimportant place. In the more advanced walks of science and mathematics the University of Cambridge is perhaps primarily to blame for this separation between the scientific method and the facts of science. But that University is rapidly making amends for its previous errors, and is, perhaps, pursuing as direct a course as possible towards the reunion of these two. Perhaps it may be that our teachers of schools and others, coming mostly from the University, have carried this unfair dichotomy into their own teaching. The fact is that we are only just beginning to awake all through the country to the immense benefit to be gained from scientific teaching, and we could not expect that, until this awakening had occurred, science should have been properly taught. At the University there are certainly the most unbounded facilities for the true teaching of science, in the maturer minds and more advanced mathematical acquirements of our students; but at the same time, the problem of uniting at schools the study of mathematics with that of the facts of nature is exactly the same problem. It is often objected, both by those engaged in teaching and by others, that an extensive knowledge of mathematics is required before we can apply it to Physical Science. This belief is perhaps one of the things which stand most in the way of the true teaching of science; but the belief is entirely erroneous. Of course a person must first acquire a knowledge of the technical forms of mathematical expressions which are to be used; but it has been found that at the very earliest stages of the learning of any mathematical subject, the application of it to the facts of nature may be taught. In this way a new life is given to the whole study, and a comprehension of it is attained, which is, at least in most cases, otherwise quite unattainable. Let us take an instance.
multidisciplinary sciences