China's Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution: Master Narratives and Post-Mao Counternarratives
R. Kraus
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/4127899
2004-07-01
Abstract:China's Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution: Master Narratives and Post-Mao Counternarratives, edited by Woei Lien Chong. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 2002. xix + 410 pp. US$80.00 (hardcover), US$34.95 (paperback). This volume explores the tension created by the Communist Party's 1991 decision to block public reassessments of the Cultural Revolution, at a time when the Red Guard generation, now in its 50s, has moved into positions of leadership throughout China's institutions. Inevitably, aging Red Guards have reflected upon the experiences of their youth, and are often dissatisfied with an official perspective that dismisses any positive aspect to their years of rebellion. Earlier versions of half of these chapters (on "Master Narratives") have appeared in China Information. These are supplemented by new essays on "Post-Mao Counternarratives". This is a very professional collection of essays. Standards of scholarship are high, and the essays are often provocative and informative. However, although reviewers do not judge books by their covers, consumers often do, so it is unfortunate that this volume's intellectual appeal is undermined by an unnecessarily ugly cover. Bernard J. ter Haar's chapter links the Cultural Revolution to a "demonological paradigm" in Chinese history. He traces the Cultural Revolution's management of violence to earlier practices, especially among the Taiping revolutionaries. The approach is idealist, leading to the odd speculation that modern China's stress on hygiene is a "replacement to fill the emptied semantic categories of the demonological paradigm" (p. 55), rather than a response to the poor quality of public sanitation. Ter Haar's explanation of the Cultural Revolution by way of ancient exorcisms fits poorly with the rest of the volume, which is overwhelmingly concerned with the Cultural Revolution's impact and later interpretations. Nick Knight undertakes to disentangle Mao from the movement which he initiated. Although many regard Mao as the puppet-master implementing a fake revolution of his own design, Knight argues that he was unable to control the movement. In contrast to most commentators, Knight does not treat the Cultural Revolution as a product of Mao's Utopian impulses. Instead, he interestingly argues that Mao's thought grew more pessimistic as the Cultural Revolution loomed, and as he replaced themes of harmony with those of struggle. Anne-Marie Brady examines China's small community of foreign experts from the Cultural Revolution's beginning through the 9th Party Congress in 1969. Rising nationalism turned xenophobic, making it difficult for foreign friends of China to support the movement without encountering a backlash. Many were treated as spies, and Chinese who were part of their personal networks were ill-treated. Some, of the experts were imprisoned, and others left China. At the lowest point, only 59 remained. Brady is nuanced in her handling of the factionalism and personal rivalries among these friends of China. Stefan Landsberger's chapter, "Deification of Mao", traces the Cultural Revolution through changes to the image of the Chairman. Most of the 27 Illustrations may be found in color on Landsberger's outstanding web site. Landsberger goes beyond poster images to include songs and other ritual aspects of the Mao cult. This chapter contains the book's clearest review of the history of the Cultural Revolution, and may be especially welcomed by newcomers. Only 124 novels were published during the Cultural Revolution. Lan Yang analyzes the 24 that have agrarian themes. …
Sociology,Political Science,History