A Novel Method for Predicting the Behavior of a Sucker Rod Pumping Unit Based on the Polished Rod Velocity

Jiaojian Yin,Hongzhang Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/math12091318
IF: 2.4
2024-04-26
Mathematics
Abstract:Fault dynamometer cards are the basis of the diagnosis technique for sucker rod pumping systems. Predicting fault cards with a pumping condition model is an economical and effective method. The usual model is described by a mixed function of the pump displacement and pump load, and it is difficult to use in the prediction method based on the analytical solution of the sucker rod string wave equation. In this paper, a normal pumping condition model described by a function of polished rod velocity is proposed. For the analytical solution of the sucker rod wave equation, an iterative prediction algorithm with pumping condition models is proposed, its convergence is analyzed, and then it is validated by classical finite difference method simulated cards and measured surface dynamometer cards. The results show that the proposed algorithm is accurate. The algorithm has a maximum relative error of 0.10% for the classical method simulated card area and 1.45% for the measured card area. The research of this paper provides an effective scheme for the design, prediction, and fault diagnosis of a sucker rod pumping system with an analytical solution.
mathematics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem this paper attempts to address is improving the prediction accuracy and fault diagnosis technology of the sucker rod pump system. Specifically, the authors propose a new method based on polished rod velocity to predict the behavior of the sucker rod pump system, overcoming the limitations of traditional methods that rely on mixed function models based on pump displacement and pump load. Traditional methods find it difficult to use analytical solutions when solving the sucker rod wave equation, while the new method establishes a normal operating condition model based on polished rod velocity and combines it with an iterative prediction algorithm to more accurately predict the behavior of the sucker rod pump system. ### Main Research Content Includes: 1. **Problem Description**: - Monitoring the working state of the sucker rod pump system is very important, but due to its complex working environment, direct monitoring is difficult. - Usually, the working state of the pump is identified by analyzing the surface dynamometer card, but it is impossible to obtain all types of fault dynamometer cards in actual oil wells. - Simulation technology is an economical and effective method to obtain dynamometer cards, but traditional models have limitations when solving the sucker rod wave equation. 2. **Proposed New Method**: - A normal operating condition model based on polished rod velocity was established. - An iterative prediction algorithm was proposed, which uses the analytical solution of the sucker rod wave equation to predict the behavior of the pump. - The convergence of the algorithm was analyzed, and the accuracy of the algorithm was verified through dynamometer cards simulated by the classical finite difference method and measured surface dynamometer cards. 3. **Verification and Discussion**: - The effectiveness of the new method was verified by comparing it with the simulation results of the classical finite difference method. - Experimental results show that the new method has high accuracy at low pumping speeds (1.4 min⁻¹), with a relative area error of only 0.02%. - At high pumping speeds (5.0 min⁻¹), after multiple iterations, the prediction results of the new method are consistent with the finite difference method, with relative area errors of -0.10% and 0.01%, respectively. - The practicality of the new method was further verified by comparing it with the actual measured dynamometer cards, with a relative area error of 1.30%. ### Conclusion: This study provides an effective method for the design, prediction, and fault diagnosis of sucker rod pump systems, especially based on analytical solutions. The new method not only improves prediction accuracy but also simplifies the complexity of the model, providing new ideas for practical applications.