Conservation versus development: uncovering divergent viewpoints of conservationists on National Parks system by Q methodology in China

Jun He,Weijia Zhou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2022.e02343
IF: 4
2022-11-23
Global Ecology and Conservation
Abstract:Currently, there is a great challenge for the Global South to strengthen protected areas for conservation, as there remain debates on the trade-off and synergies between conservation and human well-being. Differing from existing knowledge generated from individual case-studies with local specificities, this research applied Q methodology to capture the diversity and wideness of opinions from a broad range of conservationists by using China as an example, where a new National Parks (NPs) policy is currently implementing. By situating discussion on the debatable aspects, including National Parks' function, governance, and operation as well as local community involvements, the research aims to provide insights to a broader understanding of developing NPs system from conservationists' perspective on the discussion between conservation and development in the Global South. The results indicated three divergent primary NPs systems for conservation: state-led systems to achieve win-win outcomes, inclusive governance for a trade-offs, and ambiguity of governance and outcome, while the introduction of market instruments was not seen as a favorable pathway for the NPs System. Policy implications drawn from this research call for considering conservation as a priority in the context of neoliberal conservation, and further research is required with expanded involvement from social scientists to conservation science in the Chinese context.
biodiversity conservation,ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?