Abstract:A simulation study investigated how ceiling and floor effect (CFE) affect the performance of Welch's t-test, F-test, Mann-Whitney test, Kruskal-Wallis test, Scheirer-Ray-Hare-test, trimmed t-test, Bayesian t-test, and the "two one-sided tests" equivalence testing procedure. The effect of CFE on the estimate of group difference and on its confidence interval, and on Cohen's d and on its confidence interval was also evaluated. In addition, the parametric methods were applied to data transformed with log or logit function and the performance was evaluated. The notion of essential maximum from abstract measurement theory is used to formally define CFE and the principle of maximum entropy was used to derive probability distributions with essential maximum/minimum. These distributions allow the manipulation of the magnitude of CFE through a parameter. Beta, Gamma, Beta prime and Beta-binomial distributions were obtained in this way with the CFE parameter corresponding to the logarithm of the geometric mean. Wald distribution and ordered logistic regression were also included in the study due to their measure-theoretic connection to CFE, even though these models lack essential minimum/maximum. Performance in two-group, three-group and 2 × 2 factor design scenarios was investigated by fixing the group differences in terms of CFE parameter and by adjusting the base level of CFE.In general, bias and uncertainty increased with CFE. Most problematic were occasional instances of biased inference which became more certain and more biased as the magnitude of CFE increased. The bias affected the estimate of group difference, the estimate of Cohen's d and the decisions of the equivalence testing methods. Statistical methods worked best with transformed data, albeit this depended on the match between the choice of transformation and the type of CFE. Log transform worked well with Gamma and Beta prime distribution while logit transform worked well with Beta distribution. Rank-based tests showed best performance with discrete data, but it was demonstrated that even there a model derived with measurement-theoretic principles may show superior performance. Trimmed t-test showed poor performance. In the factor design, CFE prevented the detection of main effects as well as the detection of interaction. Irrespective of CFE, F-test misidentified main effects and interactions on multiple occasions. Five different constellations of main effect and interactions were investigated for each probability distribution, and weaknesses of each statistical method were identified and reported. As part of the discussion, the use of generalized linear models based on abstract measurement theory is recommended to counter CFE. Furthermore, the necessity of measure validation/calibration studies to obtain the necessary knowledge of CFE to design and select an appropriate statistical tool, is stressed.

Fragility Measures For Typical Cases

CASE-CONTROL SURVIVAL ANALYSIS WITH A GENERAL SEMIPARAMETRIC SHARED FRAILTY MODEL - A PSEUDO FULL LIKELIHOOD APPROACH

Exploring the fragility of meta-analyses in ophthalmology: a systematic review

The fragility index in randomized clinical trials supporting clinical practice guidelines for acute coronary syndrome: measuring robustness from a different perspective

Global Fragility Evaluation of Health Care Facilities with Structural and Nonstructural Components

Assessing the fragility index of randomized controlled trials supporting perioperative care guidelines: A methodological survey protocol

The Fragility of Statistical Findings in the Femoral Neck Fracture Literature: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials

Analysis of the Correspondence of the Degree of Fragility with the Way to Exercise the Force of the Hand

Multi-Dimensional Fragility of Structures: Formulation and Evaluation

Frailty Models for Pneumonia to Death with a Left‐censored Covariate

Fragility Curves of Restoration Processes for Resilience Analysis

The Fragility Of Standard Inferential Approaches In Principal Stratification Models Relative To Direct Likelihood Approaches

Fragility Based Life Cycle Loss Estimation Methodology for Critical Facilities

A study on comparisons of additive regression frailty models to counter heterogeneity: Bayesian strategies and case study

Fragility modeling practices and their implications on risk and resilience analysis: From the structure to the network scale

(Anti)Fragility and Convex Responses in Medicine

Data-Driven State Fragility Index Measurement Through Classification Methods

A measure of psychological antifragility: development and replication

Transit-Time Spin Field-Effect-Transistor

Semantic and Cognitive Tools to Aid Statistical Science: Replace Confidence and Significance by Compatibility and Surprise

Robustness of statistical methods when measure is affected by ceiling and/or floor effect