Mixed mode transition in boundary layers: Helical instability

Rikhi Bose,Paul A. Durbin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevfluids.9.063905
IF: 2.895
2024-06-13
Physical Review Fluids
Abstract:Recent [Bose and Durbin, Phys. Rev. Fluids 1 , 073602 (2016)] direct numerical simulations (DNS) of adverse- and zero-pressure-gradient boundary layers beneath moderate levels of free stream turbulence ( Tu≤2% ) revealed a mixed mode transition regime, intermediate between orderly and bypass routes. In this regime, the amplitudes of the Klebanoff streaks and instability waves are similar, and both can contribute significantly as these interact. Three-dimensional visualizations of transitional eddies revealed a helical pattern, quite distinct from the sinuous and varicose forms seen in pure bypass transition. This raises the fundamental question of whether the helical pattern could be attributed to a previously unknown instability mode. In the present work, based on stability analyses, we show that it is indeed the case. Two-dimensional stability analyses are performed herein for base flows extracted from DNS flow fields. The three-dimensional structure of the eigenfunction of the most unstable mode indeed reveals a helical pattern. The instability arises well upstream of the appearance of helical structures in flow visualizations. In DNS, fluctuations at wavelengths corresponding to the instability modes have negligible energy in the upstream region. Due to their high growth rates, these instability modes develop into helical patterns in the transition region, which quickly break down. The streak configuration leading to the formation of the helical mode instability is different from those leading to sinuous and varicose modes, analyzed in previous studies of pure bypass transition. Thus, the mixed mode precursor is the distinctive cause of helical mode transition. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.9.063905 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Open access publication funded by Max Planck Society. Published by the American Physical Society
physics, fluids & plasmas
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the spiral pattern observed during the mixed - mode transition can be attributed to a previously unknown instability. Specifically, through direct numerical simulation (DNS), the authors found that in adverse - pressure - gradient (APG) and zero - pressure - gradient (ZPG) boundary layers, when there is moderate free - stream turbulence (Tu ≤ 2%) and instability waves at supercritical Reynolds numbers, a unique spiral pattern will appear. This pattern is significantly different from the serpentine and dilatation patterns in pure bypass transition. Therefore, the question raised by the authors is: can this spiral pattern be attributed to a new instability mode? If so, how does this mode lead to the formation of the spiral structure? ### Research Background In the attached subsonic boundary layer, the transition process from laminar to turbulent flow has been described in detail through direct numerical simulation (DNS). Both the orderly transition and the bypass transition have been studied in detail. The theory of orderly transition has been established, usually starting from the exponential growth of instability waves, followed by a faster secondary instability process to form Λ - shaped vortices, and finally these vortices break up into turbulent patches. The bypass transition occurs without the growth of instability waves and is usually related to incident free - stream turbulence (FST). ### Mixed - Mode Transition Recent research has found that at moderate free - stream turbulence (Tu ≤ 2%) and supercritical Reynolds numbers, there is a true mixed - mode transition process. Three - dimensional visualization shows that the characteristics of the perturbation field in this transition process are significantly different from the serpentine and dilatation patterns in pure bypass transition, showing a spiral pattern. These spiral structures appear earlier in flow visualization and break up quickly. ### Research Methods The authors explored the origin of this spiral pattern by performing a two - dimensional stability analysis on the base flow extracted from DNS. The specific steps include: 1. **Extract the base flow**: Extract the base flow field from DNS, including the velocity components of the flow field. 2. **Linear stability analysis**: Perform a linear stability analysis on the extracted base flow and solve the perturbation equations. 3. **Eigenvalue solution**: Use an iterative method (such as the implicitly restarted Arnoldi method) to extract the eigenmodes with the highest growth rate. ### Main Findings 1. **Existence of the spiral pattern**: Through stability analysis, instability modes in the form of a spiral were indeed found. 2. **Modal characteristics**: The eigenfunction of the spiral pattern shows a spiral structure in space, and its growth rate is much higher than that of other modes. 3. **Precursor structure**: The precursor structure of the spiral pattern is formed by the overlap of low - speed and high - speed streaks, and this structure is uniquely present in the mixed - mode transition. 4. **Consistency with DNS**: Although the growth rate of the spiral pattern predicted by the stability analysis is higher than the value extracted from DNS, this difference further confirms that the spiral pattern is caused by this instability. ### Conclusions This study confirms that the spiral pattern can be attributed to a new instability mode, which is particularly prominent in the mixed - mode transition. The precursor structure of the spiral pattern is formed by the overlap of low - speed and high - speed streaks, and this structure is uniquely present in the mixed - mode transition. Although the growth rate predicted by the stability analysis is higher than the value extracted from DNS, this further supports the conclusion that the spiral pattern is caused by this instability.