Abstract:Background: Letters of recommendation (LOR) are considered by program directors (PDs) to be an integral part of the residency application. With the conversion of United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) Step 1 to a binary pass/fail outcome, LORs will likely have higher important in the application process moving forward. However, their utility in securing an interview for a particular applicant remains undetermined. This study aims to identify the applicant and LOR characteristics associated with an interview invitation. Methods: Letter writer (n = 977) characteristics were abstracted from applications (n = 264) to an individual integrated vascular surgery residency program over 2 application cycles. A validated text analysis program, Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count, was used to characterize LOR content. Applicant, letter writer, and LOR characteristics associated with an interview invitation were determined using multivariable analysis. Results: Letter writers were 70.9% vascular surgeons (VS), 23.7% PDs, and 45.4% professors. Applicants offered an interview were more likely to come from a top 50 medical school (35.2% vs 25.8%, P = 0.013) and an institution with a home vascular program (45.5% vs 34.1%, P = 0.006). Alpha Omega Alpha membership was significantly associated with interview offer (28.4%, P < 0.001). A greater proportion of letters from VS was associated with an interview offer (P < 0.001) compared with letter writers of other specialties. One or more PD letters were significantly associated with an interview offer (79.55% vs 20.45%, P = 0.008), whereas number of letters from APDs was not significantly associated with interview offer. Letters written by away institution faculty were significantly associated with interview offer (75%, P < 0.001), whereas nonclinical letters were not. Presence of one or more letters from a chair (57.95% vs 42.05%, P = 0.015) or chief (67.05% vs 32.95%, P = 0.028) was significantly associated with interview offer. Letters for applicants offered an interview had more references to research and teaching, which were more common in letters written by versus Letters written by PDs were more likely to use assertive, advertising language in favor of applicants. There were no significant applicant, letter writer, or LOR characteristics associated with a top 20 rank. Conclusions: Successful applicants were more likely to have LORs written by VS, PDs, and those of higher academic rank with references to research and teaching.

How Prominent Is Score Inflation, Gender, and Racial Bias in Orthopaedic Surgery Residency Recommendation Letters? A Systematic Review

Reply to the Letter to the Editor: How Prominent Are Gender Bias, Racial Bias, and Score Inflation in Orthopaedic Surgery Residency Recommendation Letters? A Systematic Review

Editor's Spotlight/Take 5: How Prominent Are Gender Bias, Racial Bias, and Score Inflation in Orthopaedic Surgery Residency Recommendation Letters? A Systematic Review

Evaluating the 2023 Standardized Letter of Recommendation Form in Applications to Orthopaedic Surgery Residency

Dear Program Director: An Evaluation of Implicit Bias in Letters of Recommendation for Neurosurgery Residency

Racial and Ethnic Bias in Letters of Recommendation in Academic Medicine: A Systematic Review

Racial and Gender Discrimination in Hand Surgery Letters of Recommendation

Assessment of Gender Differences in Letters of Recommendation for Physical Therapy Residency Applications

Evaluating the Impact of the Standardized Letter of Recommendation on a Successful Match in Urology Residency

Gender bias in colorectal surgery fellowship letters of recommendation

Identifying Gender and Racial Bias in Pediatric Fellowship Letters of Recommendation: Do Word Choices Influence Interview Decisions?

Letters of Reference in the Current Era

Attitudes towards and impact of letters of recommendation for anesthesiology residency applicants

Words Used in Letters of Recommendation for Pediatric Residency Applicants: Demographic Differences and Impact on Interviews

Letter of Recommendation Characteristics Associated with Interview Offer to a Vascular Surgery Residency Program

Gender bias in reference letters for residency and academic medicine: a systematic review

The content and value of letters of recommendation in the resident candidate evaluative process

Gender bias in postgraduate year one pharmacy letters of recommendation

Examining Implicit Bias Differences in Pediatric Surgical Fellowship Letters of Recommendation Using Natural Language Processing

Linguistic analysis of letters of recommendation for pediatric otolaryngology: A pilot study

A novel faculty development tool for writing a letter of recommendation