Abstract:The demand for better representation of cultural considerations in environmental management is increasingly evident. As two cases in point, ecosystem service approaches increasingly include cultural services, and resource planners recognize indigenous constituents and the cultural knowledge they hold as key to good environmental management. Accordingly, collaborations between anthropologists, planners, decision makers and biodiversity experts about the subject of culture are increasingly common-but also commonly fraught. Those whose expertise is culture often engage in such collaborations because they worry a practitioner from 'elsewhere' will employ a 'measure of culture' that is poorly or naively conceived. Those from an economic or biophysical training must grapple with the intangible properties of culture as they intersect with economic, biological or other material measures. This paper seeks to assist those who engage in collaborations to characterize cultural benefits or impacts relevant to decision-making in three ways; by: (i) considering the likely mindset of would-be collaborators; (ii) providing examples of tested approaches that might enable innovation; and (iii) characterizing the kinds of obstacles that are in principle solvable through methodological alternatives. We accomplish these tasks in part by examining three cases wherein culture was a critical variable in environmental decision making: risk management in New Zealand associated with Māori concerns about genetically modified organisms; cultural services to assist marine planning in coastal British Columbia; and a decision-making process involving a local First Nation about water flows in a regulated river in western Canada. We examine how 'culture' came to be manifest in each case, drawing from ethnographic and cultural-models interviews and using subjective metrics (recommended by theories of judgment and decision making) to express cultural concerns. We conclude that the characterization of cultural benefits and impacts is least amenable to methodological solution when prevailing cultural worldviews contain elements fundamentally at odds with efforts to quantify benefits/impacts, but that even in such cases some improvements are achievable if decision-makers are flexible regarding processes for consultation with community members and how quantification is structured.

Comparative Measurement of Citizens' Perceptions of Local Policies: A 3MC (Multinational, Multicultural, Multiregional) Approach

Environmental Attitude in the 28 Member States of the European Union: Cross-Cultural Comparisons Grounded in Incommensurable Measurement Instruments

Necessary but Insufficient: Why Measurement Invariance Tests Need Online Probing as a Complementary Tool

Quantifying Residents' Perceptions of Smart Community Construction through a Hybrid EWM-PROMETHEE II Method: A Case Study of Shenzhen, China

Culture, intangibles and metrics in environmental management

Multilevel latent class analysis with covariates: Analysis of cross-national citizenship norms with a two-stage approach

Experiments on Crowdsourcing Policy Assessment

On Concepts, Analytics, and Statistics in Comparative Policy Studies: an Introduction from the New Section Editors

Measurement Indices of Civil Society and Exploration of Their Localization

A Multicriteria Evaluation of Local E-Government in Terms of Citizen Satisfaction

Measuring Environmental Concern Through International Surveys: A Study of Cross-Cultural Equivalence with Item Response Theory and Confirmatory Factor Analysis

Acculturation attitudes: A comparison of measurement methods

Assessing mixed methods research quality in the European student mobility literature

The Need for a Recurring Large-Scale Benchmarking Survey to Continually Evaluate Sampling Methods and Administration Modes: Lessons from the 2022 Collaborative Midterm Survey

The Comparative Interest Group-survey project: design, practical lessons, and data sets

A Methodological Intervention in Cosmopolitanism Research: Cosmopolitan Dispositions Amongst Digital Natives

Understanding citizens' attitudes within user-centered digital health ecosystems: A sequential mixed method methodology including a web-survey

How Alike Are Political Values Measures?: Comparing Measures of Universal Values, Moral Foundations, Cultural Theory, and Cultural Cognition Theory

No Measure without Concept. A Critical Review on the Conceptualization and Measurement of Environmental Concern

Enhancing Spatial Analysis through Reference Multi-Criteria Methods: A Study Evaluating EU Countries in terms of Sustainable Cities and Communities

Happiness Studies and the Problem of Interpersonal Comparisons of Satisfaction: Two Histories, Three Approaches