How Alike Are Political Values Measures?: Comparing Measures of Universal Values, Moral Foundations, Cultural Theory, and Cultural Cognition Theory

Mark Brandt,Brendon Swedlow,Felicity Turner-Zwinkels,Branden B. Johnson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4050134

2022-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Political values are central to research programs in public opinion and political and social psychology, but rigorous efforts comparing such programs are rare. Political values are measured with scales whose constituent items’ overlap is largely unknown. We explore the item-level similarity in a U.S. national sample (n = 1047) for four values measures—of universal values (PVQ), moral foundations (MFQ), cultural theory (CT), and cultural cognition theory (CCT)—using network psychometric measures (assortivity, community clustering, adjusted Rand index, bridge centrality). These measures show that PVQ and CCT were the least overlapping values measures, with CT closer to CCT and MFQ, while MFQ items shared more communities with PVQ items than PVQ items shared with MFQ items (likely due to the PVQ’s broader coverage of different values). Social conservative and traditional values were top bridging items in all comparisons, tending to link the scales together. Convergence on values measures implies theoretical synergy that should be explored and developed. Conversely, areas of least overlap may suggest values that other research programs should consider as candidate values, such as PVQ values that might be incorporated into cultural theory and moral foundations theory.