Evaluation of the WHO standards to assess quality of care for children with acute respiratory infections: findings of a baseline multicentre assessment (CHOICE) in Italy

Marzia Lazzerini,Massimo Dagnelut,Paolo Dalena,Idanna Sforzi,Maristella Toniutti,Enrico Felici,Silvia Bressan,Gian Luca Trobia,Stefano Martelossi,Riccardo Lubrano,Silvia Fasoli,Federico Marchetti,Andrea Iuorio,Chiara Grisaffi,Silvia Galiazzo,Francesca Patanè,Chiara Stefani,Maria Luisa Casciana,Angela Troisi,Egidio Barbi,CHOICE study group,Marta Gagliardi,Kevin Valentino,Fabio Cardinale,Annunziata Lucarelli,Lucia Grazia Tricarico,Mariateresa De Sario,Alessandra Pisani,Maria Carla Finocchiaro,Laura Portale,Marta Arrabito,Vita Antonella Di Stefano,Stefano Masi,Marco Greco,Emiliano Talanti,Anna Madera,Paola Stillo,Rosa Santangelo,Nicolò Chiti,Vanessa Martucci,Mariateresa Sanseviero,Silvia Bloise,Alessia Marcellino,Silvia Sordelli,Mariangela Labruzzo,Francesca Tirelli,Massimo Lo Verde,Domenico Cipolla,Sarah Contorno,Roberta Parrino,Giuseppina De Rosa,Sara Dal Bo,Alessandra Iacono,Vanna Graziani,Carlotta Farneti,Francesco Oppido,Giulia Sansovini,Marcella Massarotto,Paola Crotti,Giada Sartor,Benedetta Ferro,Riccardo Pavanello,Marta Minute,Paola Moras,Ilaria Mariani,Elia Balestra,Benmario Castaldo,Marta Magnolato,Michele Maiola,Giorgio Cozzi,Alessandro Amaddeo,Alice Del Colle,Ilaria Liguoro,Michela Pandullo,Sara Rivellini,Chiara Pilotto,Paola Cogo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjpo-2024-002552
2024-08-30
Abstract:Background: Experience is lacking on the implementation of the WHO standards for improving the quality of care (QOC) for children at facility level. We describe the use of 10 prioritised WHO standard-based quality measures to assess provision of care for children with acute respiratory infections (ARI) in Italy. Methods: In a multicentre observational study across 11 emergency departments with different characteristics, we collected 10 WHO standard-based quality measures related to case management of children with ARI and no emergency/priority signs. Univariate and multivariate analyses were conducted. Results: Data from 3145 children were collected. Major differences in QOC across facilities were observed: documentation of saturation level and respiratory rate varied from 34.3% to 100% and from 10.7% to 62.7%, respectively (p<0.001); antibiotic prescription rates ranged from 22.6% to 80.0% (p<0.001), with significant differences in the pattern of prescribed antibiotic; hospitalisations rates ranged between 2.3% and 30.6% (p<0.001). When corrected for children's individual sociodemographic and clinical characteristics, the variable more consistently associated with each analysed outcome was the individual facility where the child was managed. Higher rates of antibiotics prescription (+33.1%, p<0.001) and hospitalisation (+24.7%, p<0.001) were observed for facilities in Southern Italy, while university centres were associated with lower hospitalisation rates (-13.1%, p<0.001), independently from children's characteristics. Conclusions: The use of 10 WHO standard-based measures can help quickly assess QOC for children with ARI. There is an urgent need to invest more in implementation research to identify sustainable and effective interventions to ensure that all children receive high QOC.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?