Implementation of the WHO Standards to assess the quality of paediatric care using health workers as source of data: findings of a multicentre study (CHOICE) in Italy

Ilaria Liguoro,Ilaria Mariani,Andrea Iuorio,Francesca Tirelli,Marcella Massarotto,Fabio Cardinale,Roberta Parrino,Sara Dal Bo,Sara Rivellini,Gian Luca Trobia,Kevin Valentino,Silvia Sordelli,Riccardo Lubrano,Giuseppina De Rosa,Michela Pandullo,Vita Antonella Di Stefano,Vanessa Martucci,Valentina Baltag,Egidio Barbi,Marzia Lazzerini,CHOICE Study Group,Marta Gagliardi,Chiara Grisaffi,Enrico Felici,Annunziata Lucarelli,Lucia Grazia Tricarico,Mariateresa De Sario,Alessandra Pisani,Maria Carla Finocchiaro,Laura Portale,Marta Arrabito,Francesca Patanè,Stefano Masi,Marco Greco,Emiliano Talanti,Anna Madera,Paola Stillo,Rosa Santangelo,Nicolò Chiti,Idanna Sforzi,Mariateresa Sanseviero,Silvia Bloise,Alessia Marcellino,Silvia Fasoli,Maria Luisa Casciana,Mariangela Labruzzo,Silvia Bressan,Silvia Galiazzo,Massimo Lo Verde,Domenico Cipolla,Sarah Contorno,Dal Bo Sara,Troisi Angela,Federico Marchetti,Alessandra Iacono,Vanna Graziani,Carlotta Farneti,Francesco Oppido,Giulia Sansovini,Stefano Martelossi,Chiara Stefani,Paola Crotti,Giada Sartor,Benedetta Ferro,Riccardo Pavanello,Marta Minute,Paola Moras,Paolo Dalena,Elia Balestra,Benmario Castaldo,Marta Magnolato,Michele Maiola,Cozzi Giorgio,Amaddeo Alessandro,Alice Del Colle,Massimo Dagnelut,Maristella Toniutti,Chiara Pilotto,Paola Cogo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjpo-2024-002612
2024-08-30
Abstract:Objectives: There is little experience in implementing the WHO Standards for improving the quality of care (QOC) for children. We describe the use of 75 WHO-Standard based Quality Measures to assess paediatric QOC, using health workers (HWs) as data sources. Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: 12 Italian hospitals. Participants: The minimum target of 75% of HWs was reached in all facilities; answers from 598 HWs were analysed. Primary and secondary outcome measures: 75 prioritised WHO Quality Measures were collected using a validated, and Italian-language questionnaire exploring views of HWs providing care to children. A QOC index was also calculated based on the assessed Quality Measures. Results: In both the domain of resources and work organisation, most Quality Measures showed a high overall frequency of reported 'need for improvement', with high variability across hospitals. Key needs for improvement included: availability of clear and complete protocols (eg, on paediatric emergencies: 44.6%; range 10.6%-92.6%); clear hospitalisation criteria for diarrhoea (50.5%; range 30.3%-71.7%); number of hand-washing stations (13.2%; range 3.4%-37.0%); equipped working rooms with computers for HWs (66.1%; range: 32.1%-97.0%); training (eg, on pain management: 43.5%; range 17.9%-76.7%), periodic discussion of clinical cases (43.5%; range 8.1%-83.7%) audits (48.8%; range 29.7%-76.7%); and all indicators related to system to improve QOC. Factors significantly associated with a lower QOC Index included HWs working in facilities in Southern Italy (p=0.001) and absence of a paediatric emergency department (p=0.011). Conclusions: The use of the 75 prioritised Quality Measures, specific to HWs provide valuable data on paediatric QOC, which can be used to drive a quality improvement process.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?