Enabling the collective to assist the individual: CoREAD, a self-organising reading environment
Andrew F. Chiarella,Susanne P. Lajoie
2006-10-01
Abstract:CoREAD, software that enables learners to collaborat e indirectly while reading a text, was designed using a self-organising systems approach. Using CoREAD learners highlight portions of the text they deem important. The font colour of the te xt is then modified based on the collective history f learners’ actions, indicating the importance of the ext sections (e.g. red for high importance). This dynamic text becomes a tool for future learners as they read the text and decide which sections are important. In this manner, the learners themselves – often an untapped resource assist each other. Results from a pilot study suggest that the software enables relatively stable patterns – “collective wisdom” about the text to emerge from the indirec t collaboration of the learners. Educational Context: Problem If learners in post-secondary institutions are to b ecome successful life-long learners, particularly i n professional and learned disciplines, then they require the ability to read disciplinary texts (journal articles, resea rch reports, literary analyses, etc.). Such texts are constantly being pu blished and so the knowledge they collectively cont ain is therefore very dynamic. As such, typical textbooks can not adequat ely reflect, in real-time, this changing knowledge base. However, educators have good reasons for using textbooks. Te xtbooks are designed to cover numerous topics very quickly and in a manner that (it is hoped) will be “easier” for stud ents to understand. One might well ask if the skill required to read textbooks so as to perform well on assessments are the same skills needed to grasp disciplinary texts? Does this prepare students to learn from and be critical of disciplin ary texts, for example? (also see J. S. Brown, Coll ins, & Duguid, 1989) However, disciplinary texts might prove challenging for many students who may need assistance. Feedbac k during learning has been shown to be more beneficial than feedback after the fact. Therefore, assistance while reading is needed. One way to do so would be to analyse each text base d on expert knowledge of the domain and then provid e students with hints, guiding questions, additional resources etc. Unfortunately, this is very time consuming and unl ikely to be adopted when the texts from year to year (or semester to se me ter) are constantly changing. A flexible and ada ptive system was therefore sought. The approach adopted here was to create software th t enables learners to collaborate indirectly while reading a text. As learners read expository text a simple but crucial task for successful comprehension is locating the m ost relevant information within the text (A. L. Brown & Day, 198 3; Winograd, 1984). Learners with limited prior kno wledge about the subject matter being read will be at a particul ar disadvantage (Dole, Duffy, Roehler, & Pearson, 1 991), as will those who are generally less capable readers. For this re a on, the software designed enables learners to pop ulate a text with information about the most important sections that c n then be used by future learners. In this case, the learners themselves – often an untapped resource assist ea ch other. Chiarella, A. F., & Lajoie, S. P. (2006). Enabling the collective to as sist the individual: CoREAD, a selforganising reading environment. In T. C. Reeves & S. F. Yamash it (Eds.), Proceedings of the World Conference on E-Learning in Corporate, Government, Healthcare, and Higher Education (E-Learn) (pp. 2753-2757). Chesapeake, VA: AACE.